An informal academic blog about my research and my everyday rants. I attempt to write about things that I encounter everyday which make me think. The pictures and paintings here are my own and are available for sale. The title is a tribute to the Conservative Sociologist whose blog I loved reading.
Friday, 23 May 2014
Saturday, 17 May 2014
The Death of Stuart Hall – Why Blackness is Best When it is Dead
Here's a little piece I wrote for the Black Feminists Manchester
http://blackfeministsmanchester.wordpress.com/2014/05/12/the-death-of-stuart-hall-why-blackness-is-best-when-it-is-dead/
http://blackfeministsmanchester.wordpress.com/2014/05/12/the-death-of-stuart-hall-why-blackness-is-best-when-it-is-dead/
Thursday, 8 May 2014
Vigil in Manchester
#bringbackourgirls
On the 18th April 276 young girls were abducted and have now been sold in to slavery.
In order to show solidarity and support and that we care about the whereabouts and welfare of these young girls and we want their safe return Manchester will be holding a vigil on Saturday 10th May.
Please wear RED and make your placards.
In order to show solidarity and support and that we care about the whereabouts and welfare of these young girls and we want their safe return Manchester will be holding a vigil on Saturday 10th May.
Please wear RED and make your placards.
Date- Saturday 10th May
Time- 1.00 pm -3.00 pm
Venue- Picadilly Gardens
Link to the facebook event.
Wednesday, 30 April 2014
Twitter campaign - #transpsychfail
My friend started this campaign spread the work and stat tweeting.
We are collecting critical info about trans* people being failed by the psych establishment, please tell us #transpsychfail
We are collecting critical info about trans* people being failed by the psych establishment, please tell us #transpsychfail
Tuesday, 29 April 2014
Claire's Wirral Coastal Walk
My friend Claire did this last year. this year she is doing a 15 mile walk. Please donate money for a good cause.
This is a note from Claire.
https://www.justgiving.com/cjrukwirralwalk/
This is a note from Claire.
Last year I did a sponsored walk of 8 miles to raise funds for St Catherine's Hospice, Preston as they nursed my husband, John, through the final two months of his life. The kind souls who sponsored me helped to raise over £350!!
This year I'm doing a sponsored walk to raise funds for The British Lung Foundation to help finance their battle against lung diseases such as the one (Idiopathic Pulmonary Fibrosis) that killed John.
However, the walk this year is 15 miles! That's twice as long as last year's walk so I'm hoping, in my wildest dreams, that means I will raise twice as much!!
So please do use this page to donate (and don't forget the Gift Aid!). Donating through JustGiving is simple, fast and totally secure. Your details are safe with JustGiving – they’ll never sell them on or send unwanted emails. Once you donate, they’ll send your money directly to the charity. So it’s the most efficient way to donate – saving time and cutting costs for the charity.
Thank you!
Claire xx
Link to the page where you can donate money.
https://www.justgiving.com/cjrukwirralwalk/
Sunday, 27 April 2014
What does it mean to be Trans*gender
I must say I don't understand the issue fully but I am aware that it is still classified as a mental disorder. Being labelled with a mental illness is an unpleasant experience. It also is the only way somebody can transition. Hate crime, misunderstanding and misconceptions about the issue have isolated people in the community. Through this event we hope activists in this field can share their experiences with us.
The event is free but you need a ticket. Book tickets here
Sunday, 20 April 2014
Happy Easter
Inspired by stained glass in John Rylands Library, Deansgate. Thought Tudor Roses only came in Red and white was happy to see this lovely blue one in the corridor that leads to the galleries.
Here's the original it's got a luminance to it that can only be captured in stained glass .... I had to try anyway.
Thursday, 17 April 2014
Wednesday, 16 April 2014
Indigenous people – because some of us are from mars
I will be very angry is someone throws that term around again. If there
are indigenous people there must be exogenous people. It is only a polite term
for ‘savage tribal’. The double speak is so obvious in India people categorized
as tribal’s are indigenous as if the rest of us came down from mars. The term
brings with it all the problems of old anthropology studying people in grass
skirts. It is the same today or even worse, these indigenous people are now
expected to live like stuffed animals in museum cabinets, unchanging and on
display. To be looked at spoken about as one would of an object. We are to
conform to an ideal set out by people in power, never masters of our own lives.
What is this culture? What aspects make it authentic? Language, dress,
food, music? As if those never change or evolve? What culture has ever lived an
insular life never adapting or adopting?
Liberals in the west seem to find our return to nativism charming yet a
mention this about their culture and they say that is nationalism. Why this
double standard? The language of the liberal westerner mirrors the one spoken
by the far right in postcolonial nations. I have said it before but every time
I do I get called a racist an inauthentic person, whitewashed. Tears,
screaming, shouting or silence follows what I say. This shouldn’t surprise me
all I am expected to do is cook spicy curry, talk about spirituality and be
poor.
Are we to remain frozen in time petrified on display?
Tuesday, 15 April 2014
National Preoccupations and Art or Why Aliens Don't Come to India
Abstract
The idea for this seminar began last year when during a
conversation about Indian sci-fi films came up. It started out as a joke ‘would
aliens in these films go dancing around trees as they invaded the country?’
I will be looking at the Amar Chitia Katha (eternal
picture stories) comics, their origins and content. Issues of a longer more
robust culture are often cited for India’s romanticism of its past. Its
historical fiction seems inevitable as compared to America a new nation or is
it? The subtext of this fiction is reveals what lies at the heart of these stories
and the tropes they employ.
Sonia Soans, a researcher at MMU, will be giving a talk on Indian comics and how they reflect the concerns of the society that produced them. Looking at the Amar Chitra Katha series in particular, her talk will deal with the way that Indian comics reflect stereotypical ideas about the distant past and contemporary anxieties.
Venue - Room G35 in the new business school. The room has disability access and accessible restrooms. http://www2.mmu.ac.uk/travel/allsaints/Parking around the area is usually free from 6.00 pm onwards.
Follow us on Twitter @SoniaSoanspsy & @MancsterCon
The event is free we need to know approximately how many people are coming.
The event will be livestreamed follow the link http://new.livestream.com/accounts/7978295/events/2927644
Monday, 14 April 2014
Sunday, 13 April 2014
Why do our men take their anger out on us?.......
The first time I came across that quote from Audre Lorde it felt like a weight had been lifted off my shoulders. Somebody understood the power and gender dynamic within which black women's lives operate. I fund this on Son of Baldwin's page today and had to share it. The article is attached at the bottom of the page. He has summed up my frustration on this issue "We come up with spiritual and political excuses to exempt ourselves from blame. We point out exceptions in order to discredit the rule."
While racism does exist and it is a problem one injustice shouldn't overide another.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/gordon-braxton/this-sexual-assault-victi_b_5125310.html?utm_hp_ref=fb&src=sp&comm_ref=false
While racism does exist and it is a problem one injustice shouldn't overide another.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/gordon-braxton/this-sexual-assault-victi_b_5125310.html?utm_hp_ref=fb&src=sp&comm_ref=false
Thursday, 10 April 2014
My first published review
This is the nicest lunchtime surprise. After a lovely walk around Manchester City Centre with a friend I come back and see this.
https://www.academia.edu/6711919/Psychology_of_Women_Section_Review_16_1_Spring_2014
The journal is free and online. Thanks to the people at the Psychology of Women's Section for publishing my work.
https://www.academia.edu/6711919/Psychology_of_Women_Section_Review_16_1_Spring_2014
The journal is free and online. Thanks to the people at the Psychology of Women's Section for publishing my work.
Tuesday, 1 April 2014
This is the dance of my people…..
Sitting
predominantly white seminars has taught me one thing and that is – I have
culture. Sometimes the only naturally dark skinned person is the room I have
this unique privilege of having a culture, tradition, history, dress. To some extent,
we Indians do play the ‘unique diverse and spiritual culture card’ very well,
however it is the same culture that makes us savages.
I am often meant
to say something contradictory in these seminars to validate that I have
culture. What is culture? Why don’t white people need it? How is it they don’t
have it? I am always amazed at the silliness of this lack of self awareness. The
only position I can hope to have is one of authenticity to my culture. The term
itself is loosely thrown about. everything a person of colour does is
understood to be culture and also it’s most authentic expression. We are no
longer trapped by ideas of savagery but by culture. White people no longer need
to be trapped by this part of their identity they have the freedom of choice.
Choosing from a buffet table that is culture they are still the conquerors.
Even the freedom
to choose is a cultural identity is culture itself. If white wasn’t a colour,
if English wasn’t a language, if shirts and skirts weren’t clothes, if jacket
potatoes weren’t food then white people don’t have culture. But as we do know
every human group has a tendency to form its own norms culture is inescapable.
Saturday, 29 March 2014
Not such an equal marriage
The seamier side
of things
Last night I read two important stories
on the internet – UK allows gay marriage, Gay man kills wife when she
threatened to expose him.
The first story showed pictures showed
happy white people from LGBT groups holding hands, kissing. The other story
also UK based was sickening on so many levels. A British man of Indian origin had gone back to
India to find a suitable bride whom he eventually killed. His wife found out he
was gay and threatened to leave him this is when a fight ensued and he killed
her and burnt her body.
While a certain section of British
society is celebrating its freedom another is living with dark secrets. The
hypocrisy of Indian society never fails to sicken me. So this couple married
presumably to make their parents happy fulfil a role society expects of them
and it turned out so wrong. The whole idea of the marriage seemed wrong so he
met and rejected girls who he met once- because marriage is a bit like mating
dogs. He knew he was gay and decided to marry a woman instead of coming out.
The girls family thought it was a good idea to let their daughter marry a man
they had only just met and lived in different country.
It is sad that this young woman lost her
life in such a brutal way. Looking at comments on Indian news websites most
people were of the opinion that this man had the freedom of coming out in a
country like UK, he could have moved to another town, he was financially
independent the law was on his side. The deceit and cowardice cost a young woman
her life.
It also points to the ugliness that
surrounds Indians marriages. We marry our children because it is the
respectable thing to do. Men and women are introduced to each other through
matchmakers after one or two meetings they decide to get married. This comes
from an sexually repressed society which frowns upon men and women talking to
one another it sees no problem in promoting the idea of institutionalised rape.
While a section of British society
celebrates equal marriages another one lives a life of deceit, hiding,
disguising and even murdering. While the law in UK on this issue is equal when
it comes to colour it needs to be less insular when it comes to LGBT activism.
Thursday, 6 February 2014
The cultural ghetto that Manchester can be.
Don’t get me
wrong I love this city but like every city it has its problems. To me the most
obvious one is the ghettos ethnic minorities live in or are relegated to. While
its nice to have a space of ones own the racial segregation in these localities
bothers me.
Drunk students
on a Friday night drinking too much out for a curry and vomit. A little taste
of the orient in China town. Is that what we are? Cute people of colour who
cook exotic food. Is this how culture is to be consumed? Bright shop fronts
which hide dark realities of our existence. With segregation comes ghettos,
barely a mile away from The Famous ‘Curry Mile’ is Longsight the Asian ghetto,
police sirens and ambulances used to greet me whenever I went there (so I
stopped going). Similar stories of sleaze and gendered violence can be told in
any of these exclusive localities of Manchester.
Manchester is
probably one of the few places the world I have met people from so many
nationalities but that is an elite migrating population. For the most people who have lived here long enough ghettos are a reality. What's more there is not talk of integration we are meant to remain in our place. We are to remain preserved in time and our cultures preserved. We can't be individuals only a group of people who function as a collective, on display to be used and abused. We are commodities to be served up as hot curries. This separation while amusing to a dominant few is detrimental to these communities that have been carefully preserved. We are exotic others who will never be British living on the benevolence of people who like foreign things.
To say that crime is a racial thing would play straight into the hands of racists however not to talk about these issues would be as much an injustice.
To say that crime is a racial thing would play straight into the hands of racists however not to talk about these issues would be as much an injustice.
Wednesday, 22 January 2014
Is homosexuality my culture? Why I do not agree with the emotive ‘this is our culture argument’.
In the past few
months I have been following the news about section 377 while I think the law
will only legitimise hate crime the discussion around it is what bothers me.
Either side claiming cultural supremacy on this issue it has forgotten
something vital that law in India tries to position itself above culture. Those
in favour of brining back the law think of homosexuality as a western disease
which will corrupt ‘Indian culture’. Those in favour of legalising
homosexuality call for respecting our culture and shedding Victorian morality.
While both sides do have a point about culture they forget something vital
about this fight- sexual orientation is not cultural choice and that which is
cultural is changeable. While the expression of sexuality is dictated by cultural
and historical factors these are constantly changing. Surprisingly the same
debate about culture is taking Nigeria. Both pro and anti arguments invoke
notions of ‘true Nigerian culture’. If legalising homosexuality is not ‘Indian culture’
neither is criminalising it.
What I fear in
this debate is that culture will be the focus and not homosexuality and people
who are homosexual. In a nation where hate crime by the state are justified the
law needs to go above arguments about culture and religious sentiment, after
all we are a multi cultural and multi religious nation. The law is not based on
personal liking but on ethics. While homosexuality might be distasteful to
someone it does not justify violence. Consensual sex between people of the same
sex (legal age taken into consideration) is not a crime it does not harm people
or society.
Update on 14th October 2014
I have just heard this lecture by Rahul Rao -The locations of homophobia this sums up my thoughts on why I resist the narrative 'homophobia is not native to my culture'. Nativism is something I resist personally and as an academic discourse. The LGBT issue is a pertinent one however either side builds this historical narrative which does not tackle the issue in the present. I will let you read the the paper and decide for yourself.
Click the link below for a copy of the essay.
The locations of homophobia -Rahul Rao
Update on 14th October 2014
I have just heard this lecture by Rahul Rao -The locations of homophobia this sums up my thoughts on why I resist the narrative 'homophobia is not native to my culture'. Nativism is something I resist personally and as an academic discourse. The LGBT issue is a pertinent one however either side builds this historical narrative which does not tackle the issue in the present. I will let you read the the paper and decide for yourself.
Click the link below for a copy of the essay.
The locations of homophobia -Rahul Rao
Tuesday, 14 January 2014
The culture of being offended.
While on recent
flight to India I was offered drinks I asked if they served any mulled wine .
Promptly I was told this was against company policy as celebrating Christmas
would be seen as offensive. ‘To whom?’ I asked ‘to our Indian passengers
madam’. I did not bother asking why it is the case of the British speaking for
the other as usual. India is a secular nation we celebrate as many festivals as
we can, the state even gives us holidays to do so. I have grown up celebrating
festivals with friends of every religion. While in recent years we have become
intolerant we aren’t trying to annihilate religion in order to achieve some
pseudo idea of peace.
Things are not
ideal in India religious minorities face persecution, however the state does
not deny people the right to practice their religions. We can tell the
difference between religion and fundamentalism. In Britain, on the other hand
all signs of religion equal fundamentalism and superstition. I suspect this is
a cause for a lot of antagonism amongst immigrants who are offended by the lack
of symbols and sanctity in public life.
I have grown up
learning about religions through festivals. Food offered by neighbours and
friends was a way to know them better.
It was an earnest gesture which said look I think you are important
enough for me to share my traditions with you. While I wont romanticise
religion I wont demonise it either. Yes some wars are caused due to religion
some wars are also caused by greed. I found the airlines pre-emptive
politically correct stance offensive. I am a vegetarian why not ban meat on the
fight? There would have been Brahmins and vegans on the why not ban all animal
products then.
The guilt most
British people feel for being British never ceases to amaze me. Religion, food,
festivals traditions do not racially attack people, people attack people. This
suppression of British culture has led to a quiet animosity against people of colour. While we are to be known
by our culture and spirituality the white person must be stripped of these and
made to feel invisible. As a friend pointed out recently isn’t white a colour?
This stripping away of ones identity also affects the way a person of colour is
treated polite on the surface but still thought of as an invader.
What I would
personally like to see in the Britain is not pseudo guilt over things that are
not offensive.
Thursday, 15 August 2013
Tell me about your childhood
Or the perverts idea of comfort....
Oh my daughter should talk to you she wants to be a counsellor...... all her friends confide in her...... mine too.... I think I have a talent....
If I had a penny every time I have heard that said ...... The idea that we are all disturbed and can only be healed by a warm loving soul is getting tiresome. I do think human suffering is problem that needs tackling I am not so sure confiding in these helpers of society is always the right answer. For most part these are people who have barely put their own house in order and seem to take a perverse delight in other people's misfortunes.
If suffering isn't pleasant neither is dealing with it, when someone tells me they enjoy solving other people's problems I suspect their motives. I am suspicious of the fact that they need to boast about it. feeding off another person's misery is the lowest and most ungracious thing to boast about.
It isn't surprising though we live in an era where are expected to reveal all be tormented by secret mental conditions, to discover our true selves. Our emotions are to be put on display and the magicians who can swish them away are the new powerful class. Directing our every move feeding off our misery in a self contentment that can only come from a deluded sense of self.
Maybe I am being too harsh but I have had enough of Psychiatry's little helpers.
Adam Curtis did a nice piece about this a while back think it is somewhere on this blog.
Oh my daughter should talk to you she wants to be a counsellor...... all her friends confide in her...... mine too.... I think I have a talent....
If I had a penny every time I have heard that said ...... The idea that we are all disturbed and can only be healed by a warm loving soul is getting tiresome. I do think human suffering is problem that needs tackling I am not so sure confiding in these helpers of society is always the right answer. For most part these are people who have barely put their own house in order and seem to take a perverse delight in other people's misfortunes.
If suffering isn't pleasant neither is dealing with it, when someone tells me they enjoy solving other people's problems I suspect their motives. I am suspicious of the fact that they need to boast about it. feeding off another person's misery is the lowest and most ungracious thing to boast about.
It isn't surprising though we live in an era where are expected to reveal all be tormented by secret mental conditions, to discover our true selves. Our emotions are to be put on display and the magicians who can swish them away are the new powerful class. Directing our every move feeding off our misery in a self contentment that can only come from a deluded sense of self.
Maybe I am being too harsh but I have had enough of Psychiatry's little helpers.
Adam Curtis did a nice piece about this a while back think it is somewhere on this blog.
I had to add this wonderful quote The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule -H.L. Mencken
Wednesday, 17 July 2013
The Virgin Mary and books.
Last week I was at the National Gallery in London. Being the medievalist I think I am I couldn't pass up the opportunity to look at rooms full of medieval art. It is interesting how early representations of The Virgin Mary almost always showed her reading. Engrossed deeply in her book almost unaware of the Angel Gabriel about to tell her she is to conceive a child. Even more nurturing examples of her with baby Jesus almost always depict her with a book in hand.
The paintings reflect the artists own social climate but also the way they imagine this piece of history. I am a bit tired of the whole medieval women were oppressed and all they did was wait in their helplessness for the renaissance. The evidence is out there.
These paintings have an implication it has on our theology and also on the way we constructed gender. Women and their education must have been an issue women reading books must have been an ideal. I am no theologian but those images convey a certain truth about my faith.
Searching through the internet I found this article which explains the symbolism of the paintings better than I would.
http://campus.udayton.edu/mary/meditations/olbook.htmlCase in point. This paintings is from The Mérode Altarpiece by Robert Campin It was created between 1425 and 1428.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)









