Showing posts with label Women's rights. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Women's rights. Show all posts

Wednesday, 24 June 2015

Not trans enough’ how the standard trans gender model gives in to cisgenderism


Here is an abstract of a paper that will be presented at manchester Sparkle and at the Psychology of Women's Section Conference. 


This paper challenges notions of what makes a good transgender person. In recent years the community has turned to more cisnormative ideals of gender to gain acceptance and often remain safe. The critique is not of specific people but how the transgender community is subjected to sexism, transphobia which is internalised and manifested in various ways.


This paper is going to be presented at the Psychology of Women's Conference. Here is a link to the program.

This is the abstract 

Not trans enough’ how the standard trans gender model gives in to cisgenderism – Pauline Sometimes and Sonia Soans

Abstract –
Amongst the LGBTQI community there are narratives of the ‘good trans’ person which alienate parts of the community that fail to identify according to the binary model of gender. Standard narratives about gender identity include transition from birth assigned gender and eventual hormone therapy and/or surgery. It is assumed that there is a strong desire to pass in cisgender society

Non-binary and bigendered individuals are often seen as confused and insufficiently transgender. Traditionalist views of what it entails to be transgender divides a community that is marginalised and creates a scramble for power and identification with ones oppressors. Attempting to restrict the transgender spectrum within a binary model imposed by cisgender society marginalises and excludes the most vulnerable members of society. Methodology is based upon lived experience of one of the co-authors supplemented with information published by transgender support organisations and social media postings by transgender, bigender and non-binary individuals.

Keywords: Transgender, Bigender, ‘oppositional sexism’

A free and open talk based on this paper will be given at Manchester Sparkle. For details consult the poster below 




Saturday, 2 May 2015

The Politics of Respectability- Free Comic #FCBD



Here is a comic produced by Jem Perks. Jem is a freelance illustrator whose interest lies in sci fi, fantasy and comic books styles. More of his work can be found on his website. 


Jem very kindly volunteered to illustrate my work






Using a previous blog post as a basis for the idea we present to you 'The politics of respectability'. We hope to raise awareness about how discrimination is hurtful to people and is a divisive force. We live in a climate of hate and fear, minority groups are often used as scapegoats and pitted against each other this comic hopes to challenge our stereotypes.

As it is  free comic book day #FCBD  we would like you to read and share this comic widely and do leave us suggestions and comments. Thank you :) 







Friday, 6 March 2015

White women’s burdens


I keep coming away from feminist events feeling more and more empty and disconnected with myself. Most times I am spoken at or about as if I was not in the room. I am almost never an individual but a part of a collective characterised by tradition and culture. I can only be the exotic helpless other who is tortured by tradition. I wont deny tradition, culture and religion are used against women in the global south but culture is everywhere. Even in the first world with all its liberalism is rife with culture and all the maladies that accompany it. This week my facebook page has been inundated with stories of the Delhi rapist blaming his victim for playing a part in her own rape. It is shocking news, even disgusting how someone is so oblivious of their crime. For the victims family hearing those words would have been a cruel reminder what their daughter went through.

I don’t deny the nature of the crime or its impact, it’s the manner in which this narrative has played out in the media unjust. Indian men are positioned as more vile and disgusting than men anywhere else. In the west smug stories of how culture, religion bring about violence are used to demonstrate how progressive the western world is to have thrown off those shackles and moved onto a rational society. Women are used in this debate to prove the achievements of the western world. Conny Roggeband and Mieke Verloo have written a brilliant paper on the subject of how western and migrant women are positioned in national debates in the Netherlands. The idea that migrant women of colour women suffer violence is based in reality however the same is true of white women. With the 3% conviction rate in the UK the notion of the liberal, west starts to fall apart.

Culture is everywhere and rape culture is everywhere. Everyday I see buses plastered with posters of 50 Shades of Grey indicative of rape culture in British society. Why is there such a denial that culture exists in the west? I have heard many socialists talk about how they have no culture in the west. I suspect this is racism hiding behind orientalism, exotic dress and food are thought to be the only hallmarks of culture. Sociologists have a term for this – ethnocentrism. The naïve assumption that ones way of behaving and acting were the norm and everyone else is inferior positions the non-western subject as subnormal. In India it is normal to define foreign cultures as inferior. We often use the argument that we have female goddesses which translates into respect for women. This could not be further from the truth, the existence of female deities does nothing for mortal women, neither does the law. Indian women are not liberated because of their goddesses. Western women are not liberated by their atheistic secular society. Gender violence is a part of the left socialist’s great shame. Recently a friend posted an article about the denial of violence in the left movement you can read all about it here. War On Women – It’s A Left Wing Problem Too! The debate around rights has far too long concentrated on saying hey look we are better than that 3rd world nation at least we are not…… The rights the western world fought are part of an on going struggle complacency will not keep them alive and ensure they are  enforced. In a era when right wing forces threaten to destroy these rights it is foolish to laud over past victories that have not been fully realised 

I accept India is not perfect I wont deny the documentary needs to be screened and it should lead to discussions however those discussions should not turn into a moral finger pointing match. When I was in India I saw this debate of the save Indian male as legitimate for obvious reasons in the UK I see it as unfair for the simple reason it tells women in the west this big lie that they are free and liberated. We women of colour are trapped by our culture white women are trapped in their liberal world.

References

Roggeband, C., & Verloo, M. (2007). Dutch women are liberated, migrant women are a problem: The evolution of policy frames on gender and migration in the Netherlands, 1995–2005. Social Policy & Administration, 41(3), 271-288.

Friday, 12 December 2014

Women and madness- the relationship women’s bodies occupy with regard to evolving social systems




This is an excerpt from a lecture I delivered at University of Salford today.

Images of mad women in popular art and literature have become tropes. Both these categories i.e. women and madness inhabit inferior positions in our society. When conflated they produce a voiceless subject whose exploitation is often ignored. 
Gin Lane are  print issued in 1751 by English artist William Hogarth 

Women’s bodies are politicised spaces on which patriarchal structures exert pressures to conform and normalise. Madness silences those voices and relabels them as dangerous to society. It is widely documented that women’s bodies are in constant fear of being harmed physically. In the case of the mad woman the process is institutionalised.  What constitutes madness is still a contentious issue. 
Looking at the past one can point out the obvious errors of mislabelling conditions affecting women as misunderstandings of a society that is not as advanced as ours. Take for example hysteria a condition whereby a woman’s uterus was thought to wander in her body which drove her to madness. Medicalisation of female biology has predetermined female inferiority. Immersed in our present culture psychiatric explanations seem unquestionable and even natural. I would like to argue it is harder to see discrimination in our own time, which is not very different from a previous era. Through examples of current mental disorders that pathologise women I will attempt to show how the spectre of the ‘mad woman’ still haunts our society through biologised understandings of madness.
Psychiatry has been described as system based on social control, although in a more insidious manner. Kvale (1992) asserts Psychology- all of it - is a branch of the police; psychodynamic and humanistic psychologies are the secret police". The power psychology exerts on the way we conceptualise the world around us is often unchecked. Often reifying existing prejudices in society. Women are a target population of this system. It is a well-known fact that women are not equal in most societies around the world, these inequalities are often justified by pathologising women or singling them out.

Long before David Rosenhan conducted his experiment investigative journalist Elizabeth Jane Cochrane’s conducted a similar experiment. In 1887 she published the book Ten Days in a Mad-House. It was based on her experience in an asylum for ten days. She deliberately presented  herself as a stereotypical mad woman. Conditions in the asylum were far from satisfactory. 


Here is a link the Rosenhan Experiment 


                                       

Part 1 of Ten Days in a Madhouse, audiobook




                                       
Part 2 of Ten Days in a Madhouse, audiobook

Reference/ Suggested reading:                                                                                                    
Chesler, P (1972). Women and madness. Garden City, NY: Doubleday.
Davar, B. V. (2008). From Mental Illness to Disability Choices for Women Users/Survivors of Psychiatry in Self and Identity Constructions. Indian journal of gender studies. 15(2), 261-290. Available at http://ijg.sagepub.com/content/15/2/261

Foucalt, M.(2006). History of Madness.  Edited by Jean Khalfa translated by Jonathan Murphy and Jean Khalfa. London. Routledge.

Foucault, M.(1979). Disciplined and Punish The Birth of the Prison Trans. Alan Sheridan. New York: Vintage/Random House.

Foucault,M.(1975). The Birth of the Clinic An Archeology of Medical Perception. Trans. A.M. Sheridan Smith. New York: Vintage/Random House

Kvale, S. (Ed.). (1992). Psychology and postmodernism (Vol. 9). Sage.

Lorde, A. (1978). Uses of the erotic: The erotic as power (No. 3). Crossing Pr.

Here is a the same essay in video format



Masson, J. (1992). Against Therapy. Glasgow. Fontana.

Plath, S. (2013). The bell jar (Vol. 50). GoodBook LLC.

Wetzel. J.W. (1991).Women's Experience Universal Mental Health Classification Systems: Reclaiming. 1991; 6; 8 Affilia. Retrieved from http://aff.sagepub.com/cgi/content/abstract/6/3/8



Terms to look up
Sylvia Plath effect                                                                                                                           Neurosexim                                                                                                                              Psychologisation                                                                                                                                  Hysteria

  Women and madness -Activity.
Think of the last time you saw images or heard jokes about mad women think of what ideas were being conveyed. What impact did this have on you?
Think of the way the ‘crazy cat lady’ image/joke is used and how do you think it regulates women and their lives? Think of the many ways this image is used. 
To what extent do you think your understanding of both madness and women’s nature has been determined by psychology in the mass media. 


Tuesday, 9 September 2014

Save me from the good doctor

Medical procedures are almost always justified on the basis of brining cures to a larger population for the greater good. To reject or question a procedure is seen as rejecting science and giving into superstition. I find the defence of science problematic as it positions certain kinds of knowledge as superstitious and it has created an environment where to critique science is taboo. I am sure the doctors who worked on curing Henrietta were doing this for her own good and to help future generations their goodwill is not to be questioned but their ethical standpoint should be. Non-dominant groups of people have a deep sense of suspicion towards the medical establishment which is justified their bodies are used for experimental purposes. Apart from that there is issue of being mistreated while seeking medical help. We seem to have an implicit understanding that medical procedures are invasive and violating of human dignity. 

Here is a documentary by Adam Curtis  on how Henrietta Lacks cancer cells were used without her permission for research 

Sunday, 31 August 2014

Legal rights of Indian women.


Women who go missing

A few years ago I had put a post up about human trafficking in India/Nepal. This week an acquaintance of mine was in danger. I won't go into the details except say that she is safe now. 

I worry about women and men who disappear and have no one to speak for them. In Britain many women go back to their parents home country and are forced into marriage or cured of their sexuality. The lucky ones manage find legal representation but there are so many who don't. The Southhall Black Sisters have led several campaigns against women of British origin or immigrants being taken back forcefully only to be forcefully married or had fgm performed on them. 

There are so many people out there who have no one to talk to about what they are going through and it is frightening that their deaths/lives will go unnoticed. 




Friday, 29 August 2014

Bring Christina Fronthes back home


 I regret to tell you that Christina Fonthes - a dear friend and organiser of Rainbow Noir has been held against her will in The Congo - she was on a family holiday with her mother who has decided to have Christina 'cured' of her sexuality.
Christina has managed to escape from her aunt's house and is currently hiding out with a friend. She has access to internet and has been communicating with us via email. The next available flight is 2nd September - 5 days away! Chris needs help and protection from the British Embassy in Congo but her mother has reported her missing and therefore we need to get in contact with both the UK Home Office and UK embassy in Congo to let them know that she is in danger and that her mother is lying/the one endangering her life!!
PLEASE SHARE THIS ON ALL YOUR NETWORKS. CALL, EMAIL, TWEET the British embassy on behalf of Christina - the more we call, the more attention it will bring to her case and hopefully they will act quicker in getting Christina to a safe place.
HER MOTHER HAS HER PASSPORT AND TRAVELING DOCUMENTS!
CHRISTINA'S LIFE IS IN DANGER. PLEASE DO AS MUCH AS YOU CAN.
If you need more information PM me.
UK EMBASSY: 0871 050 5840
public.enquiries@homeoffice.gsi.gov.uk
MOST RECENT UPDATE:
It has been confirmed that Christina was arrested after leaving the embassy and released back to her family where she is currently trying to negotiate her journey home. Christina's life is still in very real danger and we need to continue to raise the profile of this case on as many media channels as we can. We have no more information at this current time.
We are currently putting together a press release and a list of contacts to send it to.
If you want to help - If you have any contacts at high profile newspapers, media channels etc please forward their details to us.
See Rainbow Noir Twitter for updates. @RainbowNoirMCR

Use the hashtag   and spread the word.
Good news Christina is coming home. Thank you for all your support. However there are many men and women around the world who are not safe  

Wednesday, 30 July 2014

Bring Back Our Girls- Manchester Prayer Service


NWG invites you to our servcie to pray for young women and girls globally. Young women and girls are being used as weapons of war and conflict. Let us pray together to end such violence and inhumane behaviour against women and girls globally.