Showing posts with label violence. Show all posts
Showing posts with label violence. Show all posts

Thursday, 23 April 2015

Cutting her nose to spite his face: Violence against women in India and the collusion of power


Here is an abstract of a paper I published recently. A big thank you to the Psychology of Women's Section who thought my work was meaningful for their readers. 

The Paper is free to read and download and the link below will let you access the full paper.


Title -Cutting her nose to spite his face: Violence against women in India and the collusion of power 


Abstract -  In the last few years crime against women in India has increased dramatically. What stands out about these crimes is how the perpetrators of these crimes use violence to disable a woman; through, for example, acid attacks, ‘honour crime’ and public stripping. The perpetrators often claim to do this in order to preserve their notion of ‘Indian culture’. These notions are tied within understandings of women’s roles as submissive, chaste, modest and ‘traditional’. Women’s bodies are the primary site for this violence as disfiguring the female body sends out a cautionary message to other women not to transgress boundaries that have been laid out by those who feel they must preserve this culture. 


These understandings of ‘Indian culture’ are often invented and are tied to nationalismwhich poses a threat to ‘Westernised Indians’ particularly women. Cases such as the Delhi Gang Rape case or the attack on pubs in Mangalore which led to the ‘pink chuddi campaign’ have caught the eye of the media, however, one sees them being justified by the perpetrators on thegrounds of protecting ‘Indian culture’. When these crimes are presented in the Western media they are often collude with the perpetrators of these crimes by using these notions of ‘tradition’. Western ideas of India and how Eastern values must be preserved from Western civilisation often undermine the victim’s ordeal. 


Keywords: Gendered violence; honour crime; India; nationalism. 


Reference-  Soans, S (2015) Cutting her nose to spite his face: Violence against women in India and the collusion of power. Psychology of Women Section Review – Vol. 17 –pages 52-65



Saturday, 4 April 2015

I am your sister - Audre Lorde


I am tired of hearing about the gay agenda. I am tired of hearing about the LGBT community taking over the world. I am tired of hearing how they will spoil our children. The truth is heterosexuality breeds a certain notion of gender and violence to enforce gender.


You  can find this brilliant essay here Lorde, A. (1985). I am your sister: Black women organizing across sexualities (Vol. 3). Kitchen Table/Women of Color Press

Friday, 5 December 2014

The black guy always dies first.


My flatmate is a fencer and  loves the sport. One of his fencing friends gave him a lovely umbrella for Christmas with the handle shaped like the hilt of a sword covered in a cloth cover. It’s a lovely present I said to him this morning you should take it with you when it rains it is a big umbrella ‘I can’t carry that thing around I am back and the cops will stop me’ came his reply. That is such a painful realisation knowing you have to look a certain way so that you aren’t stopped by the authorities. Being a black man isn’t easy as bell hooks said society expects black men to be more righteous than everyone else and holds their failures up as an example of their inferiority.

My flatmate is a black man and yes he likes fencing as much as his white friends do but none of them will be stopped by a policeperson, their youth and sense of irony will never make dangerous or suspicious to the authorities. This is not the first time this has happened though, a few months ago we caught a bus one night and my flatmate got in first and found a seat for both of us the white woman opposite him cringed and tensed up till I came and sat down next to him she looked at both of us didn’t seem pleased but was pacified with my presence.

People say racism is dead do they realise there is more to racism than shouting out rude names? It is in the silences, the quiet exclusion, and the institionalised misrepresentation. Racism of the 1960’s was very different and was very obvious but a quieter racism exists now. I have seen a black academic being shouted down at an anti racist conference by people who claimed they spoke for him. My flatmate and I have a running joke between us whenever we watch a film I ask him was it one of those films where the black guy dies first. It is a terrible joke but it is based in a painful truth. We have only seen black men as disposable commodities who get in the way of white society. It doesn’t help that fiction on screen is similar to events off screen. Black men no matter how young or old are a much-vilified group.

Racism embodies our deepest fears. Knowing your teenage son can be shot at for being suspicious, knowing your education, good manners will not protect you in such a situation is a very deep seated and realistic fear. Don’t tell us we are paranoid don’t tell us we are being hysterical don’t tell us we are looking at things too deeply. Isn’t the Ferguson case and countless cases before and after it indicative institutionalised racism. I am not saying every white person is a racist or goes out of their way to attack people of colour the system is a lot deeper, its working very insidious. Just like sexism, homophobia, and other inequalities are deeply ingrained our society so is racism its in the law, it remains in society even when the law changes. It is in the everyday life of people. Knowing you have to constantly negotiate your place in society to be accepted to be respectable in the eyes of dominant groups is an inequality.

The fact that my flatmate’s first thought was I will be stopped by the cops is indicative enough of a system that has ingrained a very real fear in him. It doesn’t matter how much my flatmate likes his umbrella or how many assurances he gets deep down he knows the minute he walks out of that door he will be stopped. It wont matter that he lives an honest decent life and wouldn’t hurt a fly in the eyes of the world he will always be a dangerous black man. 

Thursday, 19 June 2014

12 years a slave and white peoples guilt


Maybe its me but I am sick of my white friends feeling guilty about slavery when they watch that film. Their sadness for the past leaves me a bit cold slavery isn’t dead yet. A few days ago I was out with a friend and after the movie screening we headed to the pub for drinks and everyone on the table had a nostalgic tone of voice when the film was mentioned. This friend who is a budding film maker said he couldn’t help but feel the movie was titillating to which there was an immediate uproar about how no one thought the film did that or felt that way. My friend was white and male and I was the only woman of colour there so as I do I sat and listened. They claimed they were sickened by the violence of their ancestors and were glad slavery was over. To which my friend pointed out slavery is still very much alive. The conversation became awkward again.

It is interesting how titillation was understood in narrow terms or rather denied. I haven’t seen the film but have heard about the scenes of sexual violence (which weren’t in the book but found a way into the film somehow). bell hooks contends this was deliberate and the exploitation of a black woman’s body is not a mere artistic trope. The denial of deriving any pleasure out of these representations is preposterous.

When the issue of modern slavery is brought up it becomes difficult to address as the benefits of slavery are many and we all benefit from them. simple narratives such as 12 years a slave make the issue more comfortable to deal with. Slavery is a thing of the past, the villains are pure evil and rather violent. All of this makes the idea of slavery seem more comfortable to deal with after all these characters nothing like us or are they? 

Tuesday, 15 February 2011

Paraphillic Coercive Disorder.



That’s what we are calling rape these days why punish the criminal when you can let them hide behind a fancy term.  It has become fashionable nowadays to find a psychological cause for everything we cant understand, we need to find a cause within the individual to absolve them from responsibility or to put the blame squarely on their shoulders.
The other day I brought this issue up the issue of medicalising rape with another psychologist who actually thought it might be a good idea. The rapist I am sure had some neurochemical imbalances which made him do it or perhaps it’s a genetic thing getting the rapist to therapy will do him/her wonders. Perhaps we can understand them better, or maybe we can make them see how wrong they are, or maybe we will change them, maybe we can release them from their inner trauma that causes them to rape, maybe maybe………… how naïve does one have to be not to see the stupidity of it all. Why not legalise rape while we are at it, and while we are at it lets look at the trauma a murderer feels when he kills.
The new DSM (diagnostic manual) is planning to include rape as a disorder. Move over victim your rapist needs to get the attention now.  I have gone hoarse pointing out how the mental health system is oppressive but this takes the cake.  The psychiatric institution has never been known for niceness towards its consumers but getting a rapist to sit in for therapy and to take away the autonomy form the crime is collusion between two oppressive forces.
Rape is not a crime of passion to call it paraphillic is absurd philia means love, rape DOES NOT INVOLVE LOVE. Forced sex isn’t sex at all it is an act of asserting power over another person. Though all rapists aren’t men most rape cases involve female victims (we may not have adequate data form male victims), one cant help but look at rape through a power structure – patriarchy.   
I don’t know how many men sat and wrote the new DSM but I have a hunch a large majority had to be men. As for calling a spade a spade the mental health field fails miserably. Why call it rape when you can give it a pretentious Latin name, which is not only misleading but will also take away some of the revulsion one feels with the term rape.  We minimise the seriousness of the crime (I still think it is a crime) by giving it a term very few people are bound to understand. The term rape conjures up violent images but the term Paraphilic Coercive Disorder does nothing of that sort the perpetrator can very easily hide behind the veil of science and obscure language. Lets call it rape and see how many people will want to include it in the DSM. Those in power benefit with the addition of the new diagnosis it allows them to wield greater power over people without actually asserting themselves too much.
In the midst of all this controversy somehow we forgot to ask the victim if they would like to share their therapist with their rapist.