Showing posts with label culture. Show all posts
Showing posts with label culture. Show all posts

Thursday, 23 April 2015

Cutting her nose to spite his face: Violence against women in India and the collusion of power


Here is an abstract of a paper I published recently. A big thank you to the Psychology of Women's Section who thought my work was meaningful for their readers. 

The Paper is free to read and download and the link below will let you access the full paper.


Title -Cutting her nose to spite his face: Violence against women in India and the collusion of power 


Abstract -  In the last few years crime against women in India has increased dramatically. What stands out about these crimes is how the perpetrators of these crimes use violence to disable a woman; through, for example, acid attacks, ‘honour crime’ and public stripping. The perpetrators often claim to do this in order to preserve their notion of ‘Indian culture’. These notions are tied within understandings of women’s roles as submissive, chaste, modest and ‘traditional’. Women’s bodies are the primary site for this violence as disfiguring the female body sends out a cautionary message to other women not to transgress boundaries that have been laid out by those who feel they must preserve this culture. 


These understandings of ‘Indian culture’ are often invented and are tied to nationalismwhich poses a threat to ‘Westernised Indians’ particularly women. Cases such as the Delhi Gang Rape case or the attack on pubs in Mangalore which led to the ‘pink chuddi campaign’ have caught the eye of the media, however, one sees them being justified by the perpetrators on thegrounds of protecting ‘Indian culture’. When these crimes are presented in the Western media they are often collude with the perpetrators of these crimes by using these notions of ‘tradition’. Western ideas of India and how Eastern values must be preserved from Western civilisation often undermine the victim’s ordeal. 


Keywords: Gendered violence; honour crime; India; nationalism. 


Reference-  Soans, S (2015) Cutting her nose to spite his face: Violence against women in India and the collusion of power. Psychology of Women Section Review – Vol. 17 –pages 52-65



Monday, 3 November 2014

Immigrants built this nation …. What if they didn’t?



With elections round the corner there is a lot of talk of  immigrants and their benefit to the nation. I had a conversation earlier this year with my priest and very rarely am I told off (I was glad I was in this case). I pointed out how good immigrants were for the economy as I contribute by paying taxes and paying for things…. I was stopped there and then and asked what if I didn’t do any of that should I be asked to leave the country?

While the anti side protests that we rob precious resources the side that supports us thinks of us in terms of how we benefit society and them. both these arguments are selfish… its just that one is less selfish than the other. I have heard people tell me how grateful they are to immigrants who built roads as there were none in Britain till we came in. Sounds like a compliment or is it? What if we didn’t build roads? I find this assumption problematic as it positions the immigrants as the new working class and can only think of them in terms of productivity. This argument calls to mind a sketch by Rowan Atkinson about immigrants and curry.

I will let you watch it.

The line now that we have got the recipe is hilarious and it points to a deeper problem – we have stopped being useful and therefore should be asked to leave. Working class immigrants are elevated and white ones demonised as scroungers which ferments animosity and has lead to the rise of groups such as the EDL.

What if we didn’t make curry, roads, or take up any job that came our way would we still be welcome? Working in jobs no one wants to is not our choice it is a necessity (we aren’t given allowed access to public funds). I agree we contribute to the economy however human society isn’t about working alone.
Is our worth to be measured only in how we can make the lives of the middle classes comfortable and exotic? 
  

PS: Comments about the previous post ruffled some feathers. Yes some white people are very nice and have wonderful personalities and good intentions which I have every right to question. Good manners are not being questioned here just the thought process around certain ideas. 

Wednesday, 29 October 2014

I dream of Africa...... Neo colonialism and the niceness of it all

I want to go to Africa for a gap year......... I had a penny for every time I heard that.....

A young chap said that to me today. At which point I nearly bit his head off. He justified it by saying Africa is poor which made me more angry. He is very young however that is no excuse really. He cited the goodness of his heart and his desire to help less fortunate people. I was told this is enough and one mustn't get cynical of good intentions. Why not? It seems sentiment and emotion must outweigh rational thought. As a woman of colour I was of course the hysterical one, cynical and not a good servant. All this good will was being offered to me and I would have none of it my ingratitude was hurting someone's good intentions. 

That this persons saw Africa as a little village full of poverty stuck children waiting for his good intentions and little loose change is to be taken for granted. His feelings are of utmost importance never-mind his blatant ignorance and misguided sense of charity or should I say voyeurism. 

There are several issues here 

1 This person refuses to see the problems in his own society- Europe is a nice place but isn't exactly perfect there are lots of homeless people here. 

2 Poverty is graded with African poverty being the worst and somehow only redeemable by a good hearted white boy.

3 Good intentions are seen to be all that one needs to change the world. Sorry economists and social workers if only you sprayed fairy dust all around you.

4 Black people are seen as people without agency and dependent on the benign goodwill of white people, their opinion in this matter is non existent.

5 Africa the continent is though of as little village which is made of all poor people who would kill each other if it were not upto white people to save them. 

6 African people are thought of as all poor with very little or no insight into the inner working of their society.

All these assumptions are racist yet questioning them makes me a hysterical cynical black woman. So the brutality of past colonisers is gone instead we have young men and women with good intentions  how have things changed? 




Thursday, 23 October 2014

Boys will be boys...... and what are little boys made off?




An overcompensatory masculinity harms men who are given to believe that being a man is scripted and includes behaving in a way that is contradictory to their inner nature and feelings, that being a part of herd is more important than being in individual. What are boys meant to be? Feminism has rightfully questioned stereotypes and how patriarchy is harmful to women and men. 

This scripted masculinity hurts women and men alike. What is constitutes masculinity has been constantly changing over time and culture. Men  were not always expected to be tough and unfeeling. 

Wednesday, 22 October 2014

Authentic natives- why nativism is destroying our activism

So it's black history month here in the UK and I am hearing a lot about native cultures and exaggerated stories of racism and glorified pasts. Good and bad things have happened in the past, however how we tell those stories and construct our identities based on them is what I am interested in. To quote MN Srinivas 'the present was so bleak that the past became glorious'. He goes on to talk about how India's past was reinvented with exaggerated claims of superiority. These claims can be seen in the way activists approach issues, through reclaiming the past. Rahul Rao has written about the use of these arguments are being disavowed cousins of the very antagonists they are fighting. 

Nativism has several problems as it goes onto to prove that we are nothing more than an unchanging history, to be petrified in time. This is an aspect of racism I have encountered in the UK, it is liberal, well meaning and positive but still racist. This argument also plays into the hands of the extreme right who use culture as a way of distinguishing between civilised white people an uncivilised black people whose are tied to their culture which makes us nasty. 

The call for authenticity for me also poses the fear of right wing groups eliminating non authentic citizens. While activists emerge from a positive position they are nevertheless using the same argument and the oppressor which does not sufficiently argue why groups of people must be treated well in the present time. 

Tuesday, 30 September 2014

Chemistry and the mundane



I heard someone remark how they thought science could contribute to how food was made. I am sure we have heard these wide eyed comments before and not just on this subject. That someone would suggest such a thing amuses me. Food is the basis of chemistry, biochemistry and the application of physics. While it is mundane it is most vital, it is probably how we learnt some of most vital aspects of dealing with chemicals. A friend of mine has always eaten cake with fascination and why not, cake she claims is the invention of a very clever chemist. Cooking is magical if you think about it, combing flavours in different way with different temperatures is very scientific, and yet we take this fro granted.

I spent this weekend making kimchi (Korean pickled cabbage). It was fascinating to think how someone came  up with the idea in the first place. The careful process of draining excess water out of cabbage, adding various spices and vegetables to the mixture all to have vegetables during a cold winter. Cheese is just as fascinating. At what moment in time did we decide to drink another animals milk and when did we realise we could cook this milk to make something completely different out of it? The first cooks probably felt a sense of adventure to create different tastes and textures, preserving food, making it more palatable, heating or cooling it. Even now when you see a good cook you get the feeling that they know something innate about combing ingredients and dishing out something tasty.

It also brings me to my next question- have we lost our most basic understanding of how things are created? As a child I was fascinated by basic experiments, it made my world come alive, boiling water bubbling away on a hot stove, a magnifying glass enlarging small objects. The very basic of these activities are some of the most profound. We live in a world where we are surrounded by very complex technology however the most basic of these is what started it all. Everything around us is technology from the humble door latch to a touch screen computer.  It is not the complex that informs the basic but the other way around. 

Wednesday, 16 April 2014

Indigenous people – because some of us are from mars



I will be very angry is someone throws that term around again. If there are indigenous people there must be exogenous people. It is only a polite term for ‘savage tribal’. The double speak is so obvious in India people categorized as tribal’s are indigenous as if the rest of us came down from mars. The term brings with it all the problems of old anthropology studying people in grass skirts. It is the same today or even worse, these indigenous people are now expected to live like stuffed animals in museum cabinets, unchanging and on display. To be looked at spoken about as one would of an object. We are to conform to an ideal set out by people in power, never masters of our own lives.
What is this culture? What aspects make it authentic? Language, dress, food, music? As if those never change or evolve? What culture has ever lived an insular life never adapting or adopting?
Liberals in the west seem to find our return to nativism charming yet a mention this about their culture and they say that is nationalism. Why this double standard? The language of the liberal westerner mirrors the one spoken by the far right in postcolonial nations. I have said it before but every time I do I get called a racist an inauthentic person, whitewashed. Tears, screaming, shouting or silence follows what I say. This shouldn’t surprise me all I am expected to do is cook spicy curry, talk about spirituality and be poor.
Are we to remain frozen in time petrified on display?

Tuesday, 1 April 2014

This is the dance of my people…..


Sitting predominantly white seminars has taught me one thing and that is – I have culture. Sometimes the only naturally dark skinned person is the room I have this unique privilege of having a culture, tradition, history, dress. To some extent, we Indians do play the ‘unique diverse and spiritual culture card’ very well, however it is the same culture that makes us savages.

I am often meant to say something contradictory in these seminars to validate that I have culture. What is culture? Why don’t white people need it? How is it they don’t have it? I am always amazed at the silliness of this lack of self awareness. The only position I can hope to have is one of authenticity to my culture. The term itself is loosely thrown about. everything a person of colour does is understood to be culture and also it’s most authentic expression. We are no longer trapped by ideas of savagery but by culture. White people no longer need to be trapped by this part of their identity they have the freedom of choice. Choosing from a buffet table that is culture they are still the conquerors.

Even the freedom to choose is a cultural identity is culture itself. If white wasn’t a colour, if English wasn’t a language, if shirts and skirts weren’t clothes, if jacket potatoes weren’t food then white people don’t have culture. But as we do know every human group has a tendency to form its own norms culture is inescapable. 

Thursday, 6 February 2014

The cultural ghetto that Manchester can be.




Don’t get me wrong I love this city but like every city it has its problems. To me the most obvious one is the ghettos ethnic minorities live in or are relegated to. While its nice to have a space of ones own the racial segregation in these localities bothers me.

Drunk students on a Friday night drinking too much out for a curry and vomit. A little taste of the orient in China town. Is that what we are? Cute people of colour who cook exotic food. Is this how culture is to be consumed? Bright shop fronts which hide dark realities of our existence. With segregation comes ghettos, barely a mile away from The Famous ‘Curry Mile’ is Longsight the Asian ghetto, police sirens and ambulances used to greet me whenever I went there (so I stopped going). Similar stories of sleaze and gendered violence can be told in any of these exclusive localities of Manchester.

Manchester is probably one of the few places the world I have met people from so many nationalities but that is an elite migrating population. For the most people who have lived here long enough ghettos are a reality. What's more there is not talk of integration we are meant to remain in our place. We are to remain preserved in time and our cultures preserved. We can't be individuals only a group of people who function as a collective, on display to be used and abused. We are commodities to be served up as hot curries. This separation while amusing to a dominant few is detrimental to these communities that have been carefully preserved. We are exotic others who will never be British living on the benevolence of people who like foreign things. 

To say that crime is a racial thing would play straight into the hands of racists however not to talk about these issues would be as much an injustice. 


Thursday, 15 August 2013

Tell me about your childhood

Or the perverts idea of comfort....

Oh my daughter should talk to you she wants to be a counsellor...... all her friends confide in her...... mine too.... I think I have a talent....

If I had a penny every time  I have heard that said ...... The idea that we are all disturbed and can only be healed by a warm loving soul is getting tiresome. I do think human suffering is  problem that needs tackling I am not so sure confiding in these helpers of society is always the right answer. For most part these are people who have barely put their own house in order and seem to take a perverse delight in other people's misfortunes.

If suffering isn't pleasant neither is dealing with it, when someone tells me they enjoy solving other people's problems I suspect their motives. I am suspicious of the fact that they need to boast about it. feeding off another person's misery is the lowest and most ungracious thing to boast about.

It isn't surprising though we live in an era where are expected to reveal all be tormented by secret mental conditions, to discover our true selves.  Our emotions are to be put on display and the magicians who can swish them away are the new powerful class. Directing our every move feeding off our misery  in a self contentment that can only come from a deluded sense of self.

Maybe I am being too harsh but I have had enough of Psychiatry's little helpers.


Adam Curtis did a nice piece about this a while back think it is somewhere on this blog.


I had to add this wonderful quote The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule -H.L. Mencken