Showing posts with label Trans*gender. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trans*gender. Show all posts

Monday, 22 February 2016

Sparkle in Manchester Cathedral 2016

Sparkle  2016 is the 12th annual National Transgender celebration, taking place on the weekend of July 8th to 10th in Manchester. It is similar to pride and  a free event, open to all. There are lots of activities through the weekend. This is an invite to Sunday morning at Manchester Cathedral service with the Cathedral community it is part of the many activities over the weekend (8th- 10th July). Transgender people their friends families and allies are welcome to join in.





Date - 10th July 2016
Time- 10.30 am
Venue - Manchester Cathedral, Victoria Street, Manchester, M3 1SX


Free admission
For a link to the Cathedral website click here

Here is a link to what the Cathedral choir sounds like.

Wednesday, 4 November 2015

Transgender Day of Remembrance


Every year transgender people are killed across the world. They are murdered due to their identity as transgender people.  At the start of the year I heard about the deaths of five transgender women the number has grown since.

In the month of November we remember them and hope that there comes a time when transgender people can live their lives in peace.

A remembrance event has been set up in Nexus Cafe on 19th November between  7.30-8.30 pm 

Har saal transgender log duniya bhar mein maare jate hain. Unkie hatya is wajeh se hoti hai kyon ki unki pechan trangender hain.  Is saal ke shuruwaat mein maine paanch hatyaon ke bare mein suna tab se yeh sankhya badti gayi hai.

November ke mahine mein hum unko yaad karte hai aur ummed karte hain ki aisa waqt aye ki transgender log apne zindagi shanti se guzaar paye. 

Unki yaad mein ek ghante ke liye hum Nexus Cafe mein 19th November ko shyam ke 7.30 se 8.30 baje tak mil rahien hai.


हर साल ट्रांसजेंडर लोग दुनिया भर में मारे जाते हैं. उनकी हत्या इस वजह सो होती है क्यों की उनकी पेचानट्रांसजेंडर हैं. इस साल के शुरुवात में मैंने पांच हत्याओं के बारे में सुना तब से यह संख्या बढ़ती गयी है. 

नवंबर के महीने में हम उनको याद करते है और उम्मीद करते हैं की ऐसा वक़्त आये की ट्रांसजेंडर लोग अपनी ज़िन्दगी शांति से गुज़ार पाये.

उनकी याद में एक घंटे के लिया हम नेक्सस कैफ़े में १९थ नवंबर को शयम के ७.३० से ८.३० बजे तक मिल रहैं है. 

Monday, 26 October 2015

Queer black representation in films


I felt rather privileged to be invited to speak as a panellist at a film festival organised by Rainbow Noir this weekend. I was amazed by the independent films I watched, some heart warming some pointing out a frightening reality experienced by QTIPOC around the world.

At the heart of this festival lay two basic ideas one to showcase Black LGBT history through cinema and the second to provide a wider representation of the LBGT community. Representation is perhaps the most important issue here. October in the UK is celebrated as Black History Month. Which while essential is not very well publicised and often is met with accusations of racism. These accusations could not be further from the truth. History is often told in an ethnocentric manner, forgetting an essential part of the process. The history of black people is often forgotten or told crudely, lacking in nuance. However even within the events organised as part of Black History Month some histories are not told.

At a conference I was earlier this month a participant spoke about how the only Black History they learnt was about slavery. Black identity is not a monolith it covers several intersectional identities, each of which have their own intellectual standpoint. In an era when LGBTQ identity is either (re)criminalised or punished by death history of the community takes on a political meaning. A  classic example is India where both pro and anti LGBTQ rights groups argue by using history as an example. Claiming and locating homosexuality either in the west or in an ancient past does little to remedy the situation at hand. Homosexuality is often spoken about as a western idea and a consequence of westernisation threatening to erode the moral fabric of ‘traditional’ society. Despite these claims LGBTQ history does exist, it does not always follow a linear path or conform to the present day narrative, it is still a history that needs telling.    

Films are perhaps the best medium to capture and transmit this history. A popular means of communication of ideas films are often used as propaganda and the mouthpiece of the nation. The three biggest cinema industries (Indian, Chinese and Hollywood) are characterised by their heteronormative content. Given the nationalistic element it comes as no surprise that most films communicate a heteronormative, patriarchal reality. LGBTQ characters if present tend not to be main characters adding very little to the plot. Then of course there is the problem of stereotyping where the LGBTQ character lacks nuances and is solely a part of the scenery. The Vito Russo Test seeks to address the issue of LGBTQ representation in films its criteria being. While it does not guarantee the film is a good representation a lot of mainstream films fail to pass this test.

Representation is  a problematic area of mass media. at its heart lies the idea that mere inclusion is not enough for representation to matter it needs to be nuanced, it needs to challenge and dismantle stereotypes. The problem with an incorrect representation is that it informs a large majority about a minority. Playing into existing fantasies about a minority  a poor representation does  not build an understanding of minorities as people. Mainstream cinema tends to be formulaic and ahistorical even when it attempts to portray history it presents an anachronistic version of history.  Black people and particularly black LGBTQ people are excluded from this cinematic history.

Watching the numerous films I did on Saturday one could see a nuanced narrative of the community, safe, precarious, dangerous, celebratory, happy and sad. These were not mainstream films, while not perfect they captured the nuanced life of the community. Thinking back of the LGBTQ films I have watched it was almost always the non-mainstream films that have done any justice to the subjects they seek to represent. This is particularly true of Indian cinema, mainstream cinema uses homosexuality as a running gag through films, gay best friends, fashion designers or butch women bodyguards are the only visibility the community receives. In contrast Indian art cinema which is not commercially viable manages to create complex characters for whom there is sympathy not scorn. Memories of March by Rituparno Ghosh is one such film that tackles homophobia, coming out of the closet and acceptance without resorting to stereotypes. While the film is by no means perfect it is mature in its depiction of the LGBTQ community in India.

As stated earlier mere presence is not always indicative of representation, knowledge of the subject (in this case the LGBTQ community) is essential. Mere visibility does not always help tackle a complex subject, as Foucault points out visibility is a trap. While it is assumed that films have little or no effect on our formation of stereotypes the idea is not true. Films represent our daily lives, our fantasies. It is no surprise then that the common Hollywood trope where the black man dies first is also a reality on the streets of America.  When the only image one sees of transgender characters is comical, promiscuous and confused is it any surprise then that those are the exact slurs used against transgender people in real life.  In my research on Bollywood films and their audience the blur between cinematic reality and mundane reality crossed paths. While whistling at raunchy musical numbers on screen the men who watched these films also extended this behaviour to women around them. Cinema is not divorced from reality neither is it a discrete entity which is contained in a cinema hall. To represent accurately is not pedanticism but a necessity.

                                                          Trailer Memories in March 

Friday, 2 October 2015

AfroFuturesUK- A free conference

Afro Futures_UK, a collective of researchers, artists, programmers and activists exploring new ways of examining blackness and futurism. We are hosting a FREE Afrofuturist Conference and Exhibition on 10th October 2015. Please join us and share widely





Monday, 31 August 2015

Queering Nationalism and nationalising the queer- An observation from Political Pride Manchester


The last weekend was busy Manchester Pride and Political Pride were both running at the same time not to mention the numerous events around the city. It is lovely to see everyone making the most of the last of summer.

While Manchester Pride was the centre of the city Political Pride was more restrained and certainly focused on the LGBTQIA community. A month before Manchester Pride shops had rainbow flags everywhere. The very same organisations that have have been pulled up in recent years for mistreatment of workers of all sexualities. This alignment with a fringe movement would seem contradictory but it is not. As one friend remarked Pride has become a family event full of rainbows where you can take your children to wave at gay people who will wave back. We have forgotten how this is a same community that was going to unleash the destruction of the family and morality. Rainbows are bright, cheerful and non-threatening. You can pick up a bag of British carrots and potatoes in a shop full of rainbow flags.

This is where the change lies the community that was once dangerous has now been domesticated. It has been given the same moral institutions that heterosexual individuals are expected to enter into- marriage. Marriage is the one institution that carries with it not only a gendered patriarchal expectation but also a nationalistic one. Gay weddings are not only good for business but also good for the national image. Gay marriage is now seen as one of the last bastions of liberation. It plays on the idea that by offering the LGBTQIA community the same ‘privileges’ as heterosexual couples equality has been achieved. It plays into the idea it is so much better out here than anywhere else where gay people are murdered.

The problem with this comparison is that it puts across a crude idea of queer liberation through the framework of national identity. Isn’t that how the right plays the immigration debate, eroding British values, their liberalism interfering with our liberal society. Needless to say we won’t be seeing a black liberation march meet such acceptance anytime soon. Pride events have come to pit one issue against another. Homosexuality is pitted against race and immigration. The apparent liberation of the LGBTQIA community is seen as a benchmark of civilisation. Is it any surprise then that this argument is used in the LGBTQIA community. In the few years I have lived here I have been told to be grateful, or asked why my country or community are homophobic. Some even going as far to say well black people have been through so much why are they so homophobic? Then of course is the other side of this propaganda black people and immigrants have it so good however being LGBTQIA is still looked down upon.

Queerness has acquired nationality in its fight for liberation. It is both a mark of liberation and national degradation. However this is not an idea that is alien to nationalism. Anne McClintock claims that all nationalisms are gendered and dangerous. Taking this argument forward it would be appropriate to say nationalism is gendered and heterosexual. Since the link between women as reproducers of culture symbolically and literally signifies the strength of the nation its obvious sexuality must also be mentioned. Given the strong connection family plays in nationalism is it any surprise that heterosexual women who fail in this expectation are immediately classified as lesbians. Similar fears exist around feminists of all sexualities whose claims are often thought of as damaging family life.  

While Britain is going through a phase where gay rights are more accepted the same cannot be said for other nations that have recriminalised homosexuality. I will stress on the word recriminalised here because it is often imagined that the history of homosexuality in the global south has been a monolith since Independence.  Recriminalising homosexuality has much to do with nationalism, as it has to do with the resurgence of religious and political extremism. Take for example Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code  which became an issue in the general election of 2014. Both sides of the debate focused very little on the present but went back to the glorious past. The liberal side arguing that our history has had a liberal interpretation of sexual identity which has only just been destroyed through colonisation. The counter argument that is put forward is that Indian values have been eroded in the recent colonial past and sexual morality must be restored. Both sides harp on the past and both do little for the LGBTQIA community in the present.

It is the liberal side of the argument that is picked up by LGBTQIA activists in the west Britain included. While the role of colonialism cannot be negated to insist that the former colonial subject is still reeling under cultural trauma denies agency and panders to homophobia. Recriminalising homosexuality in this moment of time comes as no surprise, at a time when censorship and violent opposition to anything perceived as non-Indian exist homosexuality is one of the many casualties.

History is used as a political tool to justify social exclusion. Indian history in particular has a way of making inroads into political, scientific, cultural discussion. We are both a liberal and conservative nation at the same time when it suits us. Nationality plays a role in how we view all kinds of issues. What I mean by this is that history is invoked to justify the problems of the present. Take for instance the homosexuality debate where a few random moments and exceptions in history are used as an argument. Invoking history does little for a community that lives precariously on the margins. However it is not all bad as there is still space for gay marriage in India, while homosexual activity is criminalised the law does not ban gay marriages, loophole that came under scrutiny in recent months. As in the west this was met with exhilaration, however it was short lived.  The gentleman in question and his mother put out a matrimonial advert which like the millions of adverts in Indian newspapers demanded ‘a boy of an upper caste background’.  As in the west this did not challenge the status quo but affirmed it.

The most exhilarating thing queerness can do in light of these changes is to queer gendered heterosexualised notions of the society it lives in. While it is wonderful that the law now accepts gay marriage it should not turn into the end of the discussion.  Queerness at the heart of it has the potential to challenge troubling ideas of nationality, gender, sexuality, race and class.




Wednesday, 24 June 2015

Not trans enough’ how the standard trans gender model gives in to cisgenderism


Here is an abstract of a paper that will be presented at manchester Sparkle and at the Psychology of Women's Section Conference. 


This paper challenges notions of what makes a good transgender person. In recent years the community has turned to more cisnormative ideals of gender to gain acceptance and often remain safe. The critique is not of specific people but how the transgender community is subjected to sexism, transphobia which is internalised and manifested in various ways.


This paper is going to be presented at the Psychology of Women's Conference. Here is a link to the program.

This is the abstract 

Not trans enough’ how the standard trans gender model gives in to cisgenderism – Pauline Sometimes and Sonia Soans

Abstract –
Amongst the LGBTQI community there are narratives of the ‘good trans’ person which alienate parts of the community that fail to identify according to the binary model of gender. Standard narratives about gender identity include transition from birth assigned gender and eventual hormone therapy and/or surgery. It is assumed that there is a strong desire to pass in cisgender society

Non-binary and bigendered individuals are often seen as confused and insufficiently transgender. Traditionalist views of what it entails to be transgender divides a community that is marginalised and creates a scramble for power and identification with ones oppressors. Attempting to restrict the transgender spectrum within a binary model imposed by cisgender society marginalises and excludes the most vulnerable members of society. Methodology is based upon lived experience of one of the co-authors supplemented with information published by transgender support organisations and social media postings by transgender, bigender and non-binary individuals.

Keywords: Transgender, Bigender, ‘oppositional sexism’

A free and open talk based on this paper will be given at Manchester Sparkle. For details consult the poster below 




Tuesday, 16 June 2015

@sparkleweekend in Manchester Cathedral


Sparkle is the national annual transgender festival celebrated in Manchester. It is like pride though much smaller and but packed with interesting activities and information and free. A friend of mine in conjunction with ManchesterCathedral has organised this event. It is Sunday morning service followed by cake, coffee and conversation. The service is free to attend and open to everyone. We are hoping transgender people and their allies can find a safe  worship space in the heart of Manchester. 

Wednesday, 11 February 2015

Transgender women of colour and LGBT rights

Riots in Cromptons Cafe - how the west was won. 

It is LGBT history month and often the history presented to us fails to acknowledge the contributions of the less respectable members of the LGBT community - Transgender people. Coupled with racism the movement today is largely seen as a hallmark of white progressive, liberal society. People of colour are largely forgotten or labelled as homophobic. Easy essentialisms has meant some histories have been forgotten or deliberately ignored. This documentary is about the precursor to the Stonewall riots, started by transgender women of colour it presents an history that has been deliberately ignored. 

Thursday, 5 February 2015

LGBT History Month

This is my little tribute to LGBT people this month


Coloured homosexuals have more knowledge of other cultures; have always been at the forefront (although sometimes in the closet) of all liberation struggles in this country.; have suffered more injustices and have survived them despite all odds. Page 107 Anzaldúa- Borderlands/La Frontera: The New Mestiza

Tuesday, 13 January 2015

Passing the respectability test


There are very few occasions I have encountered vile angry hate speech in Manchester. Last week was one of those occasions. I was invited out to a party on an open invitation so I took my friend along. What was seemed like a lovely evening was spoilt by some very nasty comments by a different friend who was angry with me the next day. I will tell you why you see my first friend is transgender. A fact I neglected to mention to my second friend who was most upset that I brought in someone she was not used to seeing. So while my transgender friend is white and British, she fails in another aspect of social respectability. 

My friend (the one who invited me) was angry because she could not understand why a man would dress like a woman – clearly a disorder she says. She went on to tell me her employers (the restaurant where we ate) would ‘think badly’ of her. This lady said other nasty things about my transgender friend which I have no intention of repeating. What struck me was how her hatred of my transgender friend was not just based on her prejudices and ignorance but also on looking disreputable. My transgender friend found it strange that one should think less of an LGBT person in Manchester of all places. My transphobic friend went onto tell me she thinks everyone is equal and thinks everyone must be respected equally ... wait for it she doesn't want to look like a nasty person. 

I have heard these words before 'I am not a (insert prejudice here )but ......' 'I don't want to look  .......' I wish people would acknowledge their inner prejudices rather than falsely reassure themselves of their neutrality. I also wish people would acknowledge that these prejudices are their own and not acquired for the sake of society (which is quite oblivious of them). In the wake of Leelah Alcorn's death we should not use society as an excuse to justify our own prejudices.  In India where I come from I have heard this excuse being made several times, for example parents force their children into taking certain courses at university to look good in the eyes of society. This is the same society that turns around and mocks them when their children go on to take their lives. My transphobic friend did engage with this politic being a non-British white person she would like to be accepted in British society but being heterosexual and cisgender she wants to distance herself from another kind of minority. However by making statements about another persons appearance and being nasty about it she was not being very polite or well mannered (a perception she wants others to have of her). The politics of respectability is a very convenient one, it allows the perpetrator of any kind of prejudice to deny their agency.  For example is it okay to say I am rude to you as a woman because society demands misogyny? If that statement seems ridiculous it is meant to be, it is meant to show how ridiculous some of our prejudices seem when we use the politics of respectability.

My friend hid behind her nationality, job, heterosexuality and cisgenderness to justify her prejudice and also her reaction. ‘How would that look to her employers’ was my transgender friend’s comment on the issue. That is a question that does need asking what will her employers think of her nasty reaction. Does defending an invisible uncaring society make them love us more? Do we pass if we point out the failings of another person? Twenty years ago it would have been me who would have been attacked for being the wrong skin colour. It is a fact I am always aware of, when I start passing in white society and my friends don't I am wary of this easy acceptance. I am aware it could all turn against me just as easily. I might be respectable as a cisgender woman of colour when compared with a transgender woman but if the transgender person wasn’t around I would be an outsider, this is not true equality. In another situation those same characteristics have been used against me to show solidarity with my transgender friend to include her into white respectable society. I have heard similar arguments by different immigrant groups at different points of their citizenship. Some pass the test by being good workers, some by becoming more British, but always at the cost of outing another immigrant.  My acceptance into respectable society is not a real one it is only test in which I have scored more respectable points than another person. I do not want to be accepted by people who decide what is passes as based on whims. To gain the approval of our oppressors does not make us any better than them, it only makes us become like them. My transgender friend has a good analogy for this situation – pulling up the ladder behind you she says. Unfortunately this is all too true of the politics of respectability we pull ladders up when we reach a certain stage in our lives.

I will not apologise for my friend’s appearance (which is almost always appreciated by those who meet her). I will not apologise for her not being transgender enough as all these excuses pander to our oppressors.  I will not apologise for taking her out for dinner. I will not apologise for being different.



PS: this comedy sketch explains this point well. 

Thursday, 20 November 2014

Transgender Day of Remembrance

Every year Transgender people are killed or allowed to die across the world. Some are kicked out by their families. Exploited and abused their lives are in danger. This violence must stop. Killing people is wrong. Killing people because we don't understand them is wrong. We need to accept people for who they are if you believe kindness wont change people neither will cruelty.


To my transgender brothers and sisters out there you are not forgotten. You will be missed. 

Here are some images from the memorial service at Manchester 







Monday, 11 August 2014

White man’s bait



Recently at a gathering of several transgender groups accusations were made by each group that the other was racist. All this right in front of me. It was amusing as I sat silently listening to shoddy political arguments. Either way I know where the argument was going – you don’t talk about trans people of colour – you are racist you talk about trans people of colour you are an interfering white supremacist racist.

Through all of this I was silent knowing I was invisible bait. Neither group was wrong but neither was right. Should we address issues of intersectionality – yes. Should white people get involved- yes. However throwing the race card in to prove you are not a racist I find a way to self justify one’s own discomfort with the issue.

That I was invisible during this argument proved to me I was to be spoken of in abstract terms and if I did speak I would be told off for not being authentic enough. the accusation was that there were no ethnic sounding names being called out at an event. I did try and point out that some of us have western sounding names..... I was unheard...... as I usually am. I found it insulting that we people of colour are not accepted unless we fulfil a certain stereotype. Only white people are allowed to experiment with other people's culture the rest of us must sit around being petrified in time. 

Being a transgender person of colour might have its own issues however to assume that no one in the community has thought of these issues and started their own group reeks of ignorance.

I am not anti inclusion but forced inclusion and representation is worse than not being represented at all. People of colour don’t exist to be used as political  bait neither do we exist to reassure white people of non racist they are. If your group does not have trans people of colour ask yourself if you have done something to prevent them from coming in or do they have their own groups? 

Wednesday, 30 April 2014

Twitter campaign - #transpsychfail

My friend started this campaign spread the work and stat tweeting. 

We are collecting critical info about trans* people being failed by the psych establishment, please tell us #transpsychfail

Sunday, 27 April 2014

What does it mean to be Trans*gender

I must say I don't understand the issue fully but I am aware that it is still classified as a mental disorder. Being labelled with a mental illness is an unpleasant experience. It also is the only way somebody can transition. Hate crime, misunderstanding and misconceptions about the issue have isolated people in the community. Through this event we hope activists in this field can share their experiences with us. 

The event is free but you need a ticket. Book tickets here