I was at the British museum a month ago watching an exhibition on
colonialism. What fascinated me is how India was given a certain dignity in the
art Indian women were exotic, royal and in their finest clothing (nakedness is
seen as a means of shaming and not eroticism). The African subject by contrast
was less autonomous, the women naked and objects of sexualisation. There was a stark
contrast in how the African and Asian subject was treated. One was given almost
the same dignity as the British subject even imitated. Several paintings of
white colonisers in Indian (royal) clothing were seen yet none of these existed
for their African counterparts. Colonialism was and isn’t equal. While one continent
was exoticised the other was thought of in terms of savagery. These ideas have
not vanished but continue to haunt us in the present in the way we talk about
Asians and Africans.
An informal academic blog about my research and my everyday rants. I attempt to write about things that I encounter everyday which make me think. The pictures and paintings here are my own and are available for sale. The title is a tribute to the Conservative Sociologist whose blog I loved reading.
Showing posts with label race. Show all posts
Showing posts with label race. Show all posts
Wednesday, 24 February 2016
Monday, 26 October 2015
Queer black representation in films
I felt rather privileged to be invited to speak
as a panellist at a film festival organised by Rainbow Noir this weekend. I was
amazed by the independent films I watched, some heart warming some pointing out
a frightening reality experienced by QTIPOC around the world.
At the heart of this festival lay two basic
ideas one to showcase Black LGBT history through cinema and the second to
provide a wider representation of the LBGT community. Representation is perhaps
the most important issue here. October in the UK is celebrated as Black History Month. Which while essential is not very well publicised and often is met with
accusations of racism. These accusations could not be further from the truth.
History is often told in an ethnocentric manner, forgetting an essential part
of the process. The history of black people is often forgotten or told crudely,
lacking in nuance. However even within the events organised as part of Black
History Month some histories are not told.
At a conference I was earlier this month a
participant spoke about how the only Black History they learnt was about
slavery. Black identity is not a monolith it covers several intersectional
identities, each of which have their own intellectual standpoint. In an era
when LGBTQ identity is either (re)criminalised or punished by death history of
the community takes on a political meaning. A classic example is India
where both pro and anti LGBTQ rights groups argue by using history as an
example. Claiming and locating homosexuality either in the west or in an
ancient past does little to remedy the situation at hand. Homosexuality is
often spoken about as a western idea and a consequence of westernisation
threatening to erode the moral fabric of ‘traditional’ society. Despite these
claims LGBTQ history does exist, it does not always follow a linear path or
conform to the present day narrative, it is still a history that needs telling.
Films are perhaps the best medium to capture and
transmit this history. A popular means of communication of ideas films are
often used as propaganda and the mouthpiece of the nation. The three biggest
cinema industries (Indian, Chinese and Hollywood) are characterised by their
heteronormative content. Given the nationalistic element it comes as no
surprise that most films communicate a heteronormative, patriarchal reality.
LGBTQ characters if present tend not to be main characters adding very little
to the plot. Then of course there is the problem of stereotyping where the
LGBTQ character lacks nuances and is solely a part of the scenery. The Vito Russo Test seeks to address the issue of LGBTQ representation in films its
criteria being. While it does not guarantee the film is a good representation a
lot of mainstream films fail to pass this test.
Representation is a problematic area of
mass media. at its heart lies the idea that mere inclusion is not enough for
representation to matter it needs to be nuanced, it needs to challenge and
dismantle stereotypes. The problem with an incorrect representation is that it
informs a large majority about a minority. Playing into existing fantasies
about a minority a poor representation does not build an
understanding of minorities as people. Mainstream cinema tends to be formulaic
and ahistorical even when it attempts to portray history it presents an
anachronistic version of history. Black people and particularly black
LGBTQ people are excluded from this cinematic history.
Watching the numerous films I did on Saturday
one could see a nuanced narrative of the community, safe, precarious,
dangerous, celebratory, happy and sad. These were not mainstream films, while
not perfect they captured the nuanced life of the community. Thinking back of
the LGBTQ films I have watched it was almost always the non-mainstream films
that have done any justice to the subjects they seek to represent. This is
particularly true of Indian cinema, mainstream cinema uses homosexuality as a
running gag through films, gay best friends, fashion designers or butch women
bodyguards are the only visibility the community receives. In contrast Indian
art cinema which is not commercially viable manages to create complex
characters for whom there is sympathy not scorn. Memories of March by Rituparno Ghosh is one such film that tackles homophobia, coming out of the closet and
acceptance without resorting to stereotypes. While the film is by no means
perfect it is mature in its depiction of the LGBTQ community in India.
As stated earlier mere presence is not always indicative of representation, knowledge of the subject (in this case the LGBTQ community) is essential. Mere visibility does not always help tackle a complex subject, as Foucault points out visibility is a trap. While it is assumed that films have little or no effect on our formation of stereotypes the idea is not true. Films represent our daily lives, our fantasies. It is no surprise then that the common Hollywood trope where the black man dies first is also a reality on the streets of America. When the only image one sees of transgender characters is comical, promiscuous and confused is it any surprise then that those are the exact slurs used against transgender people in real life. In my research on Bollywood films and their audience the blur between cinematic reality and mundane reality crossed paths. While whistling at raunchy musical numbers on screen the men who watched these films also extended this behaviour to women around them. Cinema is not divorced from reality neither is it a discrete entity which is contained in a cinema hall. To represent accurately is not pedanticism but a necessity.
Trailer Memories in March
Thursday, 10 September 2015
AfroFutures_UK- Free Conference/exhibition in Manchester.
This October you can be a part of AfroFutures_UK, a FREE conference/exhibition in Manchester and the first of its kind. Our seminal event will be held at the Manchester Digital Laboratory on 10th October from 10am-6pm, and will combine art & technology to present new visions of black identity through presentations, spoken word, workshops, film screenings and live performances. The day event will also be followed by an AfroFuturist themed Drag Ball at Terrace NQ, with free entrance for all backers.
Contact -
Twitter: @AfroFutures_UK
Facebook: AfroFutures_UK
Sunday, 22 February 2015
The Polical Technology Free Speech has become.
I saw
this tweet on my wall and it got me thinking about recent events and how free
speech has indeed become a technology. It is LGBT history month and I have
heard several talks on how we are now in a better place than we were.
Invariably when someone complains they are told at least we are not the 3rd
world they still criminalise homosexuality there. I admit the 3rd
world isn’t perfect but neither is the first world. This comparison does have
an element of truth in it however it is dismissive tactic. It is the same
tactic parents use to get their children to eat ‘don’t you know there are children
in Africa who have no food?’ The 3rd world is used as the dumping
ground of the world’s problems.
What
comes out in a lot of talks about LGBT history in the UK is how race can be
used to valourise ones achievements. Race and sexuality seem to be two
identities that are used to drive home a message of superiority. In India I
have heard about how superior we are as a heterosexual nation protecting
ourselves from the western invention of homosexuality. In the west I have met
white LGBT people who have insisted I am homophobic simply by existing in brown
skin. I have heard lots of nasty arguments used by both groups to prove their
superiority. I have witnessed divisions amongst the LGBT community which is
engaged in the politics of respectability. This politic is a convenient way of
seeking favour from a more powerful majority by discarding perceived
embarrassments within the community. Being a persecuted minority does not
exclude the possibility or being a persecutor of another community.
An
example that struck me recently was the way race and sexuality collided in the
film Pricilla Queen of the Desert. It is a small scene but a vital one. The
film is wonderful in the way it portrays the dangers of being transgender in
Australia yet when it comes to portraying race the film fails. A Filipino woman
in the film is shown in a negative sexualised manner. While gaining audience
sympathy for one group the film demonises another. Artistic licence allows one
to make a film as one wants however it is interesting how that was the choice
the writers made. LGBT rights have come to signify a benchmark of liberal
progressive society, societies that do not agree with this are automatically
labelled backward. Non-conformists in the LGBT community are labelled as
troublemakers. Recently a white gay man was discussing the issue of sexuality
with me and said ‘transgender people must have some disorder when you think
about it’. While his words are deeply offensive think about his privilege he is
white, male and gay he is the cream of LGBT society. It was amusing when I
pointed out how only a few decades ago he would have been locked away and
chemically castrated on those same grounds.
The
freedom to call other people names from one position of marginalisation does
not make it freedom at all. To call transgender people shouty troublemakers, or
to use derogatory language around race is a means of controlling people. It is then only a political technology and not a transformative one.
Labels:
black feminism,
LGBT,
m,
oppression,
race,
transphobia
Friday, 5 December 2014
The black guy always dies first.
My flatmate is a
fencer and loves the sport. One of his fencing friends gave him a
lovely umbrella for Christmas with the handle shaped like the hilt of a sword covered in a
cloth cover. It’s a lovely present I said to him this morning you should take
it with you when it rains it is a big umbrella ‘I can’t carry that thing around
I am back and the cops will stop me’ came his reply. That is such a painful
realisation knowing you have to look a certain way so that you aren’t stopped
by the authorities. Being a black man isn’t easy as bell hooks said society
expects black men to be more righteous than everyone else and holds their
failures up as an example of their inferiority.
My flatmate is a
black man and yes he likes fencing as much as his white friends do but none of
them will be stopped by a policeperson, their youth and sense of irony will
never make dangerous or suspicious to the authorities. This is not the first
time this has happened though, a few months ago we caught a bus one night and
my flatmate got in first and found a seat for both of us the white woman
opposite him cringed and tensed up till I came and sat down next to him she
looked at both of us didn’t seem pleased but was pacified with my presence.
People say racism
is dead do they realise there is more to racism than shouting out rude names?
It is in the silences, the quiet exclusion, and the institionalised
misrepresentation. Racism of the 1960’s was very different and was very obvious
but a quieter racism exists now. I have seen a black academic being shouted
down at an anti racist conference by people who claimed they spoke for him. My
flatmate and I have a running joke between us whenever we watch a film I ask
him was it one of those films where the black guy dies first. It is a terrible
joke but it is based in a painful truth. We have only seen black men as
disposable commodities who get in the way of white society. It doesn’t help
that fiction on screen is similar to events off screen. Black men no matter how
young or old are a much-vilified group.
Racism embodies
our deepest fears. Knowing your teenage son can be shot at for being
suspicious, knowing your education, good manners will not protect you in such a
situation is a very deep seated and realistic fear. Don’t tell us we are
paranoid don’t tell us we are being hysterical don’t tell us we are looking at
things too deeply. Isn’t the Ferguson case and countless cases before and after
it indicative institutionalised racism. I am not saying every white person is a
racist or goes out of their way to attack people of colour the system is a lot
deeper, its working very insidious. Just like sexism, homophobia, and other inequalities
are deeply ingrained our society so is racism its in the law, it remains in
society even when the law changes. It is in the everyday life of people. Knowing
you have to constantly negotiate your place in society to be accepted to be
respectable in the eyes of dominant groups is an inequality.
The fact that my
flatmate’s first thought was I will be stopped by the cops is indicative enough
of a system that has ingrained a very real fear in him. It doesn’t matter how
much my flatmate likes his umbrella or how many assurances he gets deep down he
knows the minute he walks out of that door he will be stopped. It wont matter
that he lives an honest decent life and wouldn’t hurt a fly in the eyes of the
world he will always be a dangerous black man.
Wednesday, 3 December 2014
Black people fear racism white people are scared of looking racist
I
was listening to a presentation on world hunger tonight and all the images of
hungry people were people of colour. The white people in the pictures were
helpers. One young white woman asked an uncomfortable question 'I was at Gorton
a very poor region in Manchester and some of the people didn't think we should
give aid to Africa as we don't have enough ourselves.' Everyone shifted
uneasily in the room. This was a room of 26 people 20 of whom were white middle
class university educated people in their early 20’s, the rest of us were
non-white. Only one woman of African origin sat there feeling uncomfortable. As
usual the presenter gave a vague answer about being human, helping, about
love.
I
wasn't disappointed by the answer I almost expected it. It is more important
not to look racist than be racist or let it fester. While people like my friend
are at the receiving end of these comments and in lots of cases violence white
liberalism prefers to take the moral high ground. It is easy to say to the
person of colour we don't think of you as less human - this is patronising, our
position and our protests come from experience. We have experienced
discrimination; sometimes it is a slight twitch, an uncomfortable silence or
even a patronising comment spoken slowly. When all you see of yourself is as a
hungry person all the powerful see of us is our hunger and helplessness it
forms a deep association in our mind. Images are powerful and
subconsciously affect how we perceive the world around us. For those in non
dominant positions those images are the only representations they see of
themselves and if they are negative representations they create an
I live in a
poor neighbourhood full of poor white people who are constantly vilified and
called lazy none of which is true. I can see why they hate me, I am the new toy
in the hands of the liberal, and I know I will be discarded similarly. It
hurts me that something as simple as this is never explained but left to
fester.
I don’t hate or
fear the people of Gorton they have very real concerns which I feel must be
answered rationally without resorting
to mere sentimentalism.
Wednesday, 29 October 2014
I dream of Africa...... Neo colonialism and the niceness of it all
I want to go to Africa for a gap year......... I had a penny for every time I heard that.....
A young chap said that to me today. At which point I nearly bit his head off. He justified it by saying Africa is poor which made me more angry. He is very young however that is no excuse really. He cited the goodness of his heart and his desire to help less fortunate people. I was told this is enough and one mustn't get cynical of good intentions. Why not? It seems sentiment and emotion must outweigh rational thought. As a woman of colour I was of course the hysterical one, cynical and not a good servant. All this good will was being offered to me and I would have none of it my ingratitude was hurting someone's good intentions.
That this persons saw Africa as a little village full of poverty stuck children waiting for his good intentions and little loose change is to be taken for granted. His feelings are of utmost importance never-mind his blatant ignorance and misguided sense of charity or should I say voyeurism.
There are several issues here
1 This person refuses to see the problems in his own society- Europe is a nice place but isn't exactly perfect there are lots of homeless people here.
2 Poverty is graded with African poverty being the worst and somehow only redeemable by a good hearted white boy.
3 Good intentions are seen to be all that one needs to change the world. Sorry economists and social workers if only you sprayed fairy dust all around you.
4 Black people are seen as people without agency and dependent on the benign goodwill of white people, their opinion in this matter is non existent.
5 Africa the continent is though of as little village which is made of all poor people who would kill each other if it were not upto white people to save them.
6 African people are thought of as all poor with very little or no insight into the inner working of their society.
All these assumptions are racist yet questioning them makes me a hysterical cynical black woman. So the brutality of past colonisers is gone instead we have young men and women with good intentions how have things changed?
Wednesday, 22 October 2014
Authentic natives- why nativism is destroying our activism
So it's black history month here in the UK and I am hearing a lot about native cultures and exaggerated stories of racism and glorified pasts. Good and bad things have happened in the past, however how we tell those stories and construct our identities based on them is what I am interested in. To quote MN Srinivas 'the present was so bleak that the past became glorious'. He goes on to talk about how India's past was reinvented with exaggerated claims of superiority. These claims can be seen in the way activists approach issues, through reclaiming the past. Rahul Rao has written about the use of these arguments are being disavowed cousins of the very antagonists they are fighting.
Nativism has several problems as it goes onto to prove that we are nothing more than an unchanging history, to be petrified in time. This is an aspect of racism I have encountered in the UK, it is liberal, well meaning and positive but still racist. This argument also plays into the hands of the extreme right who use culture as a way of distinguishing between civilised white people an uncivilised black people whose are tied to their culture which makes us nasty.
The call for authenticity for me also poses the fear of right wing groups eliminating non authentic citizens. While activists emerge from a positive position they are nevertheless using the same argument and the oppressor which does not sufficiently argue why groups of people must be treated well in the present time.
Monday, 6 October 2014
For the love of poor black people
I got chatting with a young Englishman yesterday who as most English people go was polite and well mannered and I wont hold that against him. We got chatting about racism or rather about the silly things people say to me. At the end of the conversation he said to me 'I believe the poor in India are very happy which is unlike this country.' This is someone who comes from an affluent family and claims he has material comforts which don't make you happy. Fair enough material things don't make you happy but does not having hot water and good make you happy?
I personally think this makes a mockery of the poor and is a lazy stereotype. It is also a complacent position. To be fair to him I have heard Indians say the same. If poverty is so good then why don't we all give everything up and live in poverty to be exploited? Not knowing when where and what you will eat again makes you happy now, or being sold into slavery?
This is intellectual laziness but also insensitive white liberal racism. This is by far the most difficult prejudice to fight because the person who holds such views generally isn't a misanthrope but just misguided. There is a sense of goodness in this person and I wouldn't want that turning into cynicism, however that they are insensitive to the plight of people i would like them to change that.
If white poor people are ungrateful to the affluent classes in England they are the same in India the difference is poor 3rd world citizens are privileged for their exoticism, thereby alienating white working class people. Is it any surprise the EDL is anti non white people? White working class people are demonised in the UK the same can't be said for their non white counterparts. A case in point is an internet meme about how immigrants built everything in Britain which is why we must be nice to them. Before us exotic types came in poor white people were exploited but have now fallen out of fashion. If liberals really cared they would change things for the poor rather than love them with cloying sentimentality.
Tuesday, 9 September 2014
Save me from the good doctor
Medical procedures are almost always justified on the basis of brining cures to a larger population for the greater good. To reject or question a procedure is seen as rejecting science and giving into superstition. I find the defence of science problematic as it positions certain kinds of knowledge as superstitious and it has created an environment where to critique science is taboo. I am sure the doctors who worked on curing Henrietta were doing this for her own good and to help future generations their goodwill is not to be questioned but their ethical standpoint should be. Non-dominant groups of people have a deep sense of suspicion towards the medical establishment which is justified their bodies are used for experimental purposes. Apart from that there is issue of being mistreated while seeking medical help. We seem to have an implicit understanding that medical procedures are invasive and violating of human dignity.
Here is a documentary by Adam Curtis on how Henrietta Lacks cancer cells were used without her permission for research
Here is a documentary by Adam Curtis on how Henrietta Lacks cancer cells were used without her permission for research
Saturday, 17 May 2014
The Death of Stuart Hall – Why Blackness is Best When it is Dead
Here's a little piece I wrote for the Black Feminists Manchester
http://blackfeministsmanchester.wordpress.com/2014/05/12/the-death-of-stuart-hall-why-blackness-is-best-when-it-is-dead/
http://blackfeministsmanchester.wordpress.com/2014/05/12/the-death-of-stuart-hall-why-blackness-is-best-when-it-is-dead/
Sunday, 13 April 2014
Why do our men take their anger out on us?.......
The first time I came across that quote from Audre Lorde it felt like a weight had been lifted off my shoulders. Somebody understood the power and gender dynamic within which black women's lives operate. I fund this on Son of Baldwin's page today and had to share it. The article is attached at the bottom of the page. He has summed up my frustration on this issue "We come up with spiritual and political excuses to exempt ourselves from blame. We point out exceptions in order to discredit the rule."
While racism does exist and it is a problem one injustice shouldn't overide another.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/gordon-braxton/this-sexual-assault-victi_b_5125310.html?utm_hp_ref=fb&src=sp&comm_ref=false
While racism does exist and it is a problem one injustice shouldn't overide another.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/gordon-braxton/this-sexual-assault-victi_b_5125310.html?utm_hp_ref=fb&src=sp&comm_ref=false
Tuesday, 14 January 2014
The culture of being offended.
While on recent
flight to India I was offered drinks I asked if they served any mulled wine .
Promptly I was told this was against company policy as celebrating Christmas
would be seen as offensive. ‘To whom?’ I asked ‘to our Indian passengers
madam’. I did not bother asking why it is the case of the British speaking for
the other as usual. India is a secular nation we celebrate as many festivals as
we can, the state even gives us holidays to do so. I have grown up celebrating
festivals with friends of every religion. While in recent years we have become
intolerant we aren’t trying to annihilate religion in order to achieve some
pseudo idea of peace.
Things are not
ideal in India religious minorities face persecution, however the state does
not deny people the right to practice their religions. We can tell the
difference between religion and fundamentalism. In Britain, on the other hand
all signs of religion equal fundamentalism and superstition. I suspect this is
a cause for a lot of antagonism amongst immigrants who are offended by the lack
of symbols and sanctity in public life.
I have grown up
learning about religions through festivals. Food offered by neighbours and
friends was a way to know them better.
It was an earnest gesture which said look I think you are important
enough for me to share my traditions with you. While I wont romanticise
religion I wont demonise it either. Yes some wars are caused due to religion
some wars are also caused by greed. I found the airlines pre-emptive
politically correct stance offensive. I am a vegetarian why not ban meat on the
fight? There would have been Brahmins and vegans on the why not ban all animal
products then.
The guilt most
British people feel for being British never ceases to amaze me. Religion, food,
festivals traditions do not racially attack people, people attack people. This
suppression of British culture has led to a quiet animosity against people of colour. While we are to be known
by our culture and spirituality the white person must be stripped of these and
made to feel invisible. As a friend pointed out recently isn’t white a colour?
This stripping away of ones identity also affects the way a person of colour is
treated polite on the surface but still thought of as an invader.
What I would
personally like to see in the Britain is not pseudo guilt over things that are
not offensive.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

