Showing posts with label Cinema. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cinema. Show all posts

Monday, 18 April 2016

Of drunk men, national struggle and renaissance.



While writing about addiction in cinema I could not help but write about Devdas.  Based on the Bengali novella of the same name by Sarat Chandra Chattopadhyay 15th September 1876 – 16th January 1938). Published in 1917 the novella was written in 1901. Depicting the life of an indecisive obsessive man with little courage. Turned into a romantic tale over the years the film evokes pity-turning Devdas into the ultimate fallen hero of Indian cinema.  In over one century Devdas has been Adapted for film, theater and television and translated into several Indian languages. The earliest film based on the book was made in 1928. 

The 2002 Bollywood version of the film brought the story back to popularity. However the film was more about the visual effects and nostalgia than the original abject nature of the titular character of book.  Chattopadhyay makes a scathing commentary about the modern educated man of his time. Torn between a stereotype and being a rational man this book continues to provide an analysis of human emotions. 

Wednesday, 16 March 2016

Review of Miss Hokusai


I recently watched Miss Hokusai and was mesmerized by the beauty of the animation. The film depicts the life of the Hokusai family focusing not on Katsushika Hokusai  (1760 – 1849) the famous woodblock print artist but on his artist daughter. The film incorporates Hokusai's artworks into the narrative giving the work context and the plot meaning.
 
What I found fascinating about the film was the lack of romance and a simple narrative which explored the characters more deeply. The film portrays a determined and sensitive young woman who keenly observes the world around her incorporating it into her painting. Her young blind sister brings out the maternal in her. 
 
As mentioned before the lack of  a romantic subplot allows the film to develop and the characters to grow in maturity without being distracted. Miss Hokusai is a single woman whose talent while admirable seems to intimidate the men around her who admire her but don't see her as a romantic partner. Her strong sense of duty coupled with her talent make her content within herself and her world.
 
The animation is beautiful conveying a range of emotions and providing a breathtaking experience. The changing seasons an little detail from Hokusai's prints were cleverly woven into the story and provided animation to prints we have only seen as still.

What I personally found interesting was the way a story of two artists were told in a historical setting with the focus not on Hokusai the artist but his daughter. The stories within the stories were equally compelling and animated with skill.

PS: This film passes the Bechdel test. 

 

Monday, 26 October 2015

Queer black representation in films


I felt rather privileged to be invited to speak as a panellist at a film festival organised by Rainbow Noir this weekend. I was amazed by the independent films I watched, some heart warming some pointing out a frightening reality experienced by QTIPOC around the world.

At the heart of this festival lay two basic ideas one to showcase Black LGBT history through cinema and the second to provide a wider representation of the LBGT community. Representation is perhaps the most important issue here. October in the UK is celebrated as Black History Month. Which while essential is not very well publicised and often is met with accusations of racism. These accusations could not be further from the truth. History is often told in an ethnocentric manner, forgetting an essential part of the process. The history of black people is often forgotten or told crudely, lacking in nuance. However even within the events organised as part of Black History Month some histories are not told.

At a conference I was earlier this month a participant spoke about how the only Black History they learnt was about slavery. Black identity is not a monolith it covers several intersectional identities, each of which have their own intellectual standpoint. In an era when LGBTQ identity is either (re)criminalised or punished by death history of the community takes on a political meaning. A  classic example is India where both pro and anti LGBTQ rights groups argue by using history as an example. Claiming and locating homosexuality either in the west or in an ancient past does little to remedy the situation at hand. Homosexuality is often spoken about as a western idea and a consequence of westernisation threatening to erode the moral fabric of ‘traditional’ society. Despite these claims LGBTQ history does exist, it does not always follow a linear path or conform to the present day narrative, it is still a history that needs telling.    

Films are perhaps the best medium to capture and transmit this history. A popular means of communication of ideas films are often used as propaganda and the mouthpiece of the nation. The three biggest cinema industries (Indian, Chinese and Hollywood) are characterised by their heteronormative content. Given the nationalistic element it comes as no surprise that most films communicate a heteronormative, patriarchal reality. LGBTQ characters if present tend not to be main characters adding very little to the plot. Then of course there is the problem of stereotyping where the LGBTQ character lacks nuances and is solely a part of the scenery. The Vito Russo Test seeks to address the issue of LGBTQ representation in films its criteria being. While it does not guarantee the film is a good representation a lot of mainstream films fail to pass this test.

Representation is  a problematic area of mass media. at its heart lies the idea that mere inclusion is not enough for representation to matter it needs to be nuanced, it needs to challenge and dismantle stereotypes. The problem with an incorrect representation is that it informs a large majority about a minority. Playing into existing fantasies about a minority  a poor representation does  not build an understanding of minorities as people. Mainstream cinema tends to be formulaic and ahistorical even when it attempts to portray history it presents an anachronistic version of history.  Black people and particularly black LGBTQ people are excluded from this cinematic history.

Watching the numerous films I did on Saturday one could see a nuanced narrative of the community, safe, precarious, dangerous, celebratory, happy and sad. These were not mainstream films, while not perfect they captured the nuanced life of the community. Thinking back of the LGBTQ films I have watched it was almost always the non-mainstream films that have done any justice to the subjects they seek to represent. This is particularly true of Indian cinema, mainstream cinema uses homosexuality as a running gag through films, gay best friends, fashion designers or butch women bodyguards are the only visibility the community receives. In contrast Indian art cinema which is not commercially viable manages to create complex characters for whom there is sympathy not scorn. Memories of March by Rituparno Ghosh is one such film that tackles homophobia, coming out of the closet and acceptance without resorting to stereotypes. While the film is by no means perfect it is mature in its depiction of the LGBTQ community in India.

As stated earlier mere presence is not always indicative of representation, knowledge of the subject (in this case the LGBTQ community) is essential. Mere visibility does not always help tackle a complex subject, as Foucault points out visibility is a trap. While it is assumed that films have little or no effect on our formation of stereotypes the idea is not true. Films represent our daily lives, our fantasies. It is no surprise then that the common Hollywood trope where the black man dies first is also a reality on the streets of America.  When the only image one sees of transgender characters is comical, promiscuous and confused is it any surprise then that those are the exact slurs used against transgender people in real life.  In my research on Bollywood films and their audience the blur between cinematic reality and mundane reality crossed paths. While whistling at raunchy musical numbers on screen the men who watched these films also extended this behaviour to women around them. Cinema is not divorced from reality neither is it a discrete entity which is contained in a cinema hall. To represent accurately is not pedanticism but a necessity.

                                                          Trailer Memories in March 

Monday, 24 August 2015

Why representation matters in popular media.


The issue of representation is important in popular media yet it is problematic, divided on the basis that media does not affect real life decisions which makes the issue seem irrelevant. It has often been pointed out that on screen violence is not enacted out despite viewing numerous films portraying destruction of life and property. The commonsensical appeal of this claim might seem obvious yet representation is not an issue of imitation nor is it of mere inclusion.

Fictional worlds created by mass media are often thought of as unreal and devoid of the social context in which they are created. This claim often makes the issue of representation seem absurd. If popular media is only a means of entertainment then accurate portrayals are seen as hindering the plot. This could not be further from the truth creating fictional characters is a deliberate act on the part of the creators it is far from accidental.

The challenge to create fair and ethical representation comes from feminist, postcolonial, queer, disability rights theorists demanding the same right to a be treated with dignity. The influence representation has on our understanding of the world should not be underestimated. Chimamanda Ngozi Adiche in her now famous speech cautions us against the ‘danger of a single story’, as an African woman studying in the west being constantly thought of as a starving African of charity advertisements brought to light how the entire continent was viewed. Similarly other individuals of minority groups have encountered negative stereotyping through their representation. In light of this evidence it would be futile to argue that representation does not matter or have an influence.   

A large section of popular media plays into easy tropes, black men dying first, stalking a woman till she says yes, LGBTQ people looking and behaving in an awkward promiscuous manner. These aren’t part of a few exceptional films or comics this the majority of mainstream media. While the entertainment value of these stories is not being questioned the intention and underlying prejudice is. Theorists such as bell hooks and Stuart Hall question the intent of the fantasy being portrayed. Questioning representation and the fantasy they are meant to convey is at the heart of the issue. To bell hooks choices made by directors, artists, writers and photographers are important. Choice which has been reduced to the personal is (re)politicised by hooks who claims choice are not made in isolation but are a product of racial political, historic and economic forces.  Neoliberal ideology would have us think otherwise. The physical screen then takes on the projection of our fantasies which as hooks points out fulfil our desires. Sexual, racial and economic exploitation on screen are indicative of how we are limited in our imaginations. A good example of this would be the show sense8, which has been critiqued on the grounds that it does injustice to minority characters. Similarly comic books take on a similar trope a white, able bodied man with a past trauma saves the world. The appeal of the genre must not be underestimated. These are popular and even cultural landmarks to dismantle the assumptions on which they stand on would seem counterproductive. We are used to a certain narrative one in which there are heroes and villains, damsels in distress, where the guy gets the girl. The comfort found in popular narratives in indicative of why alternative cinema is still a small-scale industry.

Restoring the order of things a popular narrative does not challenge preconceived notions of society around us. Prejudices and violence in our everyday life are projected onto the screen and vice versa. The process works both ways. Take James Bond for instance a fictional spy whose is often seen as unprofessional to people who work in this field. Bond is British, upper class, well-spoken, intelligent, heterosexual cisgender. His life is glamorous he kills foreign villains who threaten the British way of life and manages to find women who are attracted to him. Bond represents a strong heterosexual male desire. His actions are a glamourised version of foreign policy which has systematically destroyed lives. When contextualised the same characters seem disturbing and almost villainous.

Popular media is rooted in trade, economic forces that govern its production and propagation must not be forgotten.

An urgent economy slices through   protocols of entertainment and opens onto a critique of ‘trade’ and of commercial imperatives that drive the Culture Industry. Where frequency of representation cannot annul the complicity of critics, the self declared impresarios of distraction, the purveyors of content, the advocates of lyrical and sonic seduction and the facilitators of fabulous ‘flavours of transnational capital’, all owe a great deal to the multicultural trick that sells exotica as race relations and visibility as redress. John Hutnyk

Producing commercially viable entertainment is a priority which had lead to either ignoring ‘alternative stories’ or adapting them in such a manner that they scarcely resemble their origins. 

In her now iconic graphic novel Dykes to Watch Out For Alison Bechdel has two unnamed characters talk about the kind of films they would like to watch. The strip titled ‘The Rule’ has now come to be known as the Bechdel Test. Consisting of three rules

1 It has to have at least two women in it,
2 Who talk to each other and,
3 About something besides a man.

While this test was never meant to be a serious commentary on representation, nevertheless when used a lot of Hollywood films failed to pass these criteria. Other minority groups to monitor the treatment they receive on screen have adapted the test accordingly.

Representation is not just the mere inclusion of minority characters, a vague understanding of political correctness it is an ethical stance to treat fictional characters with dignity. 

Footnote: The Rule aka Bechdel Test


The full strip is available online from Bechdel’s personal Flickr stream (Bechdel, 1985). 

Reference:

hooks, b. (2014) Are You Still a Slave?. Universities & Education Event Tue May, 6 2014 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rJk0hNROvz


hooks, b. 1996. Reel to reel: Race, sex, and class at the movies, New York: Routledge

Hutnyk , J .(2000). Critique of exotica: music, politics, and the culture industry. London : Pluto Press.

Wainaina, B  How to Write about Africa http://granta.com/how-to-write-about-africa/


Monday, 17 August 2015

Anachronism and the film


Rey Chow’s work has inspired me to watch Chinese cinema. The issues she brings up about the presentation of gender and history. Mainstream Chinese films are enjoyable, they are shot aesthetically and feature lovely costumes and actors. However there is a problem of representation in these films. As someone who watches films to substantiate academic arguments representation becomes a vital issue in understanding the mindset of the director and also of the audience.
Mainstream films are enjoyable primarily because they pander to our expectations.  Take for instance Red Cliff released in 200 by Director John Woo who openly acknowledged he took liberties with historical accounts to make the story appeal to a modern audience. This film is one of many historical dramas to misrepresent history. While the artist does have a choice in the production of their art it is important to understand which choices they make and why. China has a long history, one which it is very proud of yet watching these films is gives the viewer very little information about history but appeals to their expectations. Perhaps this obsession with presenting a comfortable view of history is tied to what Rachel Dwyer has to say about Indian cinemas use of history in film.

“Hindi cinema interprets Indian history, telling stories about the nation – whether under threat or victorious; about sexuality and gender, looking at great figures of the past, implying a contrast with the present; and other such themes, rather than trying to represent accurately the given historical moment. The past is used then as a heterotopia, or another place, more often than a heterochronia, or different time. It is then used to tell us more about the present than the present itself can.”

Both Indian and Chinese cinema seem to present history in a manner that is convenient to telling truths about the present. This is a deliberate attempt to domesticate history to tame it to our convenience. 



Postscript: While I have critiqued Asian cinema for its use of anachronism I do not exempt Hollywood for its deliberate omission of minority characters


Reference:

Dwyer, R. (2010) ‘Bollywood’s India: Hindi cinema as a guide to modern India.’
Asian Affairs, 41(3) pp. 381-398.



Thursday, 4 December 2014

India and ET



Studying the history of Indian cinema has taught me things I was not previously aware of. The film ET for instance has Indian origins….. and no I am not one of those people who claim everything comes from India. An unfinished project by Satyajit Ray was the basis of the much loved American film. Personally I didn’t think aliens and sci fi films were subjects we were preoccupied with India but there you go. 

Monday, 29 September 2014

How do you measure feminism in films?



Is there a test to measure feminism in films? – Yes there is hooray! Ok so I have jumped the gun. Here’s the back story before I give you my take on the issue.

The Bechdel test was introduced by Alison Bechdel ( an American graphic novelist) in her comic strip 'Dykes to Watch Out For' (1985). In a strip titled ‘ The Rule’ two female characters  are talking to each one of them says to the other that she only watches a movie if it satisfies the three following requirements:
  1.  It has to have at least two women in it,
  2. Who talk to each other,
  3. About something besides a man.

And here is the strip.
Image taken from http://dykestowatchoutfor.com/the-rule. There is more info about the strip on the website.


 Bechdel has been ambivalent of the test. It was never meant to be making a strong feminist statement, it was a joke. 

Ok so it doesn’t really measure feminist content or indicates if the film is feminist friendly, it does however point out that a lot of films don’t meet some of these criteria. Feminism and its portrayal is a lot more complex. The test only indicates if women are represented on screen in a certain way. Spin offs of the Bechdel test have looked at LGBT issues etc…. You get the idea. It is interesting how most popular films are not representative of minority groups …. although ones does not expect such films to be representative. A friend recently wrote about how Expendables 3 did not pass the Bechdel test, did anyone expect it would? To be self-critical I would ask why not? Why shouldn’t popular entertainment reflect my reality or a fictionalised version of it on screen? The Bechdel test does not allude to being a feminist test to point the way out, but it does point out how women don’t have any role to play in films except for filling a gap in the narrative. This does not indicate if the film is one that deserves critical attention. Popular cinema has no such responsibility, it is meant to play on our prejudices.

Feminism and other isms are complex issues that are bigger than mere representation. Popular cinema might incorporate such issues in but only throws them in the main narrative as subplots. Or when popular cinema pretends to have taken criticism of itself aboard it subverts criticism to create the same material but sells it as ethically engaging. Chick flicks are meant to be female friendly films but they end up presenting a very narrow vision of what women can be. Closer home Bollywood films claim to be empowering women by including 'item numbers' and bikini scenes. Emotive and positive terms such as empowering are misleading, but they seem to work for the filmmakers. I would like to go into detail about why I resist an emotive culture but that is for later.  Representation is important os is the quality of the narrative in which these  are involved. 

Friday, 19 September 2014

Exotic and exploited the role of women in Indian films




I have never liked popular cinema in India, it gets on my nerves to be quite honest. I am not fond of all art cinema either. Both genres have a purpose for their existence.

Both genres have one thing in common they are eroticised. Here in the UK most people I talk to speak of the popular Bollywood films they have seen – man and woman dancing around a tree. A few people might have watched some of the nicer films – I can have intellectual conversations with those people.
Popular Indian cinema isn’t made to be meaningful, it plays on easy stereotypes to get its point across, and in short it is misrepresentative and offensive to many marginalised groups. However art cinema is expected to be more realistic and in touch with common people and their everyday struggles. I was reading this article by Madhu Kishwar on ‘Bandit Queen’. Kishwar for those of you who don’t know is an Indian feminist who has a popular magazine called Manushi. Bandit Queen is a film that is supposedly based on the life of Phoolan Devi. The film ran into controversy when it was released in 1994. I was in school at that time, I had heard about this ‘adult film in hushed tones. The film is graphic in its depiction of violence against women. In some quarters it was the film men would watch for titillation, this is nothing new men watch films like this India often. Cinema halls cater to the sexual needs of men who often learn about sexuality through films, the nature of the film does not matter as long as it is portraying women sexually.  

There was talk of the film being criticised by Phoolan herself which I remembered were dismissed by people on the grounds that she was being greedy and asking for the director for more money. However this article by Kishwar highlights another aspect of the film – it is a distorted and even eroticised narrative of violence against women in rural India. Being an art film it was to have a limited audience in India but a wider one around the world. Kishwar argues that liberties have been taken in narrating this story on screen, narratives which weren’t part of the book by Mala Sen on the subject of Phoolan’s life. It is understandable why this film was upsetting for Phoolan and why it could have sparked violence across the region.

My issue with the film and Indian films in general is how rape is commonly depicted and how it is a deliberate addition by the filmmakers to either entertain (in popular cinema) or to empathise (in art cinema). Both these reasons are insensitive to this issue or rape and sexual violence against women, which is easily dismissed in India. Phoolan was a poor illiterate woman, her story made the director lots of money. There are two issues here, Phoolan does not mention the rape in her interviews or in the book written by Mala Sen. The other issue is legal – one is not allowed to disclose the identity of a rape victim in India. However the spectacle of a naked woman exploited on screen is emotive and plays on our sense of right and wrong. It made audiences feel bad about the condition of women in rural India, however it played on a popular sentiment – India as a backward and horrible place for women. None of those accusations are false, however that is the only narrative one sees of India. The story presented in the film is not completely false it is a reality in India- except it is not Phoolan’s reality. It is made to sell a very disturbing idea of female sexuality that we have come to normalise.

Can Indian cinema ever portray women without offending them? Can any other cinema do that? bell hooks would argue otherwise as would Laura Mulvey. Sexualisation of women on screen is so common it is hard to realise it is there. Sexualised images of women are so common that they rarely get criticised. Indian women’s bodies are exploited on screen and off, this hardly gets anyone’s attention the exploitation that is. hooks contends that the makers of popular entertainment are not naïve but are guided by profit and popularity when constructing this misogyny. These stories are sold as compelling truths about Indian women. Again these cinematic liberties to portray a certain reality are carefully constructed image of women. both hooks and Kishwar point out how these stories gain credibility through depictions of  violence against women.

I remember while talking about 12 years a slave a friend pointed out how the violence presented in the film was made for titillation rather than raise the issue of slavery. The argument he presented was that it was easy to portray slavery from the past but modern day slavery would implicate us all as consumers of slavery which is a very disturbing idea and not something that would sell. Similarly the image of a certain kind of Indian woman being exploited in remote central India is not disturbing for most of us. The violence is exoticised, it is presented as alien to urban masses, who feel secure in knowing this is not their reality.

Should stories on such issues be made – yes, however they need to made with sensitivity with accuracy and not for titillation.



This is a link to the article by Madhu Kishwar –

Monday, 4 August 2014

Rachel Dwyer on Bollywood and the world.


From the video description - Rachel Dwyer is a Professor of Indian Cultures and Cinema, School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London, and author of One Hundred Bollywood Films, Filming the Gods: Religion and Indian Cinema, and Bollywood's India: Hindi Cinema as a Guide to Modern India.

This video analyses Bollywood and its creation of national history. What I find interesting in this talk is how revolutionary material is sublimated and is a product of the zeitgiest. Unlike Rachel I am not fond of Bollywood films my critiques of the art form comes from the lack of representation and also the content which I find offensive. 

However Rachel sums up the nationalistic preoccupation's Indians have which is reflected in cinema. 


Thursday, 19 June 2014

12 years a slave and white peoples guilt


Maybe its me but I am sick of my white friends feeling guilty about slavery when they watch that film. Their sadness for the past leaves me a bit cold slavery isn’t dead yet. A few days ago I was out with a friend and after the movie screening we headed to the pub for drinks and everyone on the table had a nostalgic tone of voice when the film was mentioned. This friend who is a budding film maker said he couldn’t help but feel the movie was titillating to which there was an immediate uproar about how no one thought the film did that or felt that way. My friend was white and male and I was the only woman of colour there so as I do I sat and listened. They claimed they were sickened by the violence of their ancestors and were glad slavery was over. To which my friend pointed out slavery is still very much alive. The conversation became awkward again.

It is interesting how titillation was understood in narrow terms or rather denied. I haven’t seen the film but have heard about the scenes of sexual violence (which weren’t in the book but found a way into the film somehow). bell hooks contends this was deliberate and the exploitation of a black woman’s body is not a mere artistic trope. The denial of deriving any pleasure out of these representations is preposterous.

When the issue of modern slavery is brought up it becomes difficult to address as the benefits of slavery are many and we all benefit from them. simple narratives such as 12 years a slave make the issue more comfortable to deal with. Slavery is a thing of the past, the villains are pure evil and rather violent. All of this makes the idea of slavery seem more comfortable to deal with after all these characters nothing like us or are they? 

Tuesday, 4 June 2013

We used to be known for cinema now we have man and woman dancing around a tree.




I am using films as a methodology in my thesis. Discussing this the other night with a friend made me realise while Indian cinema is now technologically at par with the west it lacks something fundamentally when it comes to writing stories. This has not always been the case. Bollywood films have at times toppled the dominance of Hollywood winning awards and being remembered for telling universal stories that people could relate to. Between the 1940’s and the present day a lot has changed, from this noble, uplifting thing we now have a cinema that says nothing about the human condition but titillates and creates an imagined India. 
The obvious cardboard sets, painted scenery and hastily put costumes were not a hindrance when it came to telling the story. Post independence cinema had all the elements we now consider hallmarks of Bollywood yet they were not mere entertainment. Even the minor characters contributed in some way. I remember watching black and white films about challenging the caste system, skin colour, unwed mothers and so many issues which are still realties. I do not see those films anymore. The 80’s for me was a decade of films with ear piercing romantic songs, man woman and lots of synchronised dancing around trees. The 90’s was about action films. Then the 2000’s saw a return to fluff and over the top affluence and glamour. I do remember art films but they were too few and in recent years always are banned. Often because they depicted a sexual scene, funny as there is worse stuff on mainstream cinema. I have seen mainstream popular films and frankly, they are not the stuff to watch with your kids or anyone for that matter. Art films deglamourise sex yet they become contentious.
What has changed since 1950? Why have we become complacent? We seem to have become a culture that is content to see women’s bodies being used and abused on screen all in the name of entertainment. We seem to look at a screen for three hours and not think or be challenged.