Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Psychology. Show all posts

Sunday, 12 April 2015

A very female malady


It doesn't take a degree in Psychology to know mental illness is gendered...... having said that it has taken me a few degrees to get to that conclusion. In my masters I learnt disorders have a gender, alcoholism for men depression for women. These distinctions are not new mental illness has been tied to gender for a long time. Hysteria is a prime example, wandering uteruses caused women to turn mad (insert behaving unacceptably), we now know internal organs don’t move instead we blame women’s hormones on their fluctuating mood. Women are emotional and not very rational we are told. Anyone who had witnessed men watching sport can vouch for strong emotions accompanied by violence being displayed.  Why is football violence seen as unemotional and the product of a rational mind or war for that matter? Why is a woman natural response to a bad situation indicative of pathology attributed to her anatomy?

It would be very easy to dismiss psychiatry of the past as unsophisticated in its diagnosis and treatment but have we changed? Do we ignore the present because we are entrenched in it?  We accept female hormones make women emotional wrecks, that their menstrual cycles control them. These ideas need to be questioned, as do their purpose. Mental illness serves a very strategic position in our world, it helps us lock away undesirable individuals in asylums when prisons wont take them. It also helps control individuals by telling them how to behave.

Open any women’s magazine and they are full of advice by psychologists and counsellors. Popular psychology magazines are similar in content if not style in this regard. I often look at issues of Cosmopolitan, Good Housekeeping and Psychology at my supermarket till and they all have the same content and intent. We have become accustomed to being corrected by an all pervasive psychology that controls every aspect of our being. Gender is on the top of that list. Symptoms of mental illness are not stable as are its manifestations.

Location also influences the production and maintenance of mental illness. Culture bound syndromes is what the International Classification of Diseases calls conditions that are only prevalent in one culture. This too is an area that is seldom questioned if conditions such as depression and ADHD were produced in the west how is it they aren’t culture bound?

The symptoms of mental illness are culturally manufactured I have found. Alcoholism and addiction while understood as universal manifest themselves differently across the world. While clinically individuals may appear the same their diagnosis is based on their age, class, gender, race, ethnicity and many other factors. Women who are diagnosed with this very male condition are often seen as worse than the men. This is an idea commonly found in rehabilitations and in scientific literature. Women occupy a strained relationship with madness, often their gender is used against them to diagnose and treat them.

Reference:
Chesler, P. (2005). Women and madness. Palgrave Macmillan.
Culture, Continuity and Breast Cancer- Agnes Arnold- Forster  http://www.historytoday.com/agnes-arnold-forster/culture-continuity-and-breast-cancer

Thursday, 15 August 2013

Tell me about your childhood

Or the perverts idea of comfort....

Oh my daughter should talk to you she wants to be a counsellor...... all her friends confide in her...... mine too.... I think I have a talent....

If I had a penny every time  I have heard that said ...... The idea that we are all disturbed and can only be healed by a warm loving soul is getting tiresome. I do think human suffering is  problem that needs tackling I am not so sure confiding in these helpers of society is always the right answer. For most part these are people who have barely put their own house in order and seem to take a perverse delight in other people's misfortunes.

If suffering isn't pleasant neither is dealing with it, when someone tells me they enjoy solving other people's problems I suspect their motives. I am suspicious of the fact that they need to boast about it. feeding off another person's misery is the lowest and most ungracious thing to boast about.

It isn't surprising though we live in an era where are expected to reveal all be tormented by secret mental conditions, to discover our true selves.  Our emotions are to be put on display and the magicians who can swish them away are the new powerful class. Directing our every move feeding off our misery  in a self contentment that can only come from a deluded sense of self.

Maybe I am being too harsh but I have had enough of Psychiatry's little helpers.


Adam Curtis did a nice piece about this a while back think it is somewhere on this blog.


I had to add this wonderful quote The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule -H.L. Mencken

Thursday, 11 August 2011

Art Therapy in Bangalore - a Conversation with Brother Mani. Part -2


What do a hands closed in prayer have in common with gothic Churches?
What do south Indian women have in common with Buddhists?


This is the second part of the interview with Brother Mani, an art therapist and Anil his assistant.  



This interview looks at how an art therapy session is conducted in a group or individually. Both Brother Mani and his assistant Anil talk about how they have used art therapy.    


Art therapy does not have a singular history but has multiple histories depending on when and where want to trace its history. Art has always been with us even in caves we had a need to decorate or use art to express ourselves. The history of art therapy is usually traced in the west during the early part of the 20th century however art has always been with us and it is not something new.

I have attached some of the artwork that is referred to in the interview. 


Here is a link to the interview      http://www.sendspace.com/file/qsawez


Murals made by the participants being put up on the walls to form a large collage










Brother Mani and Anil









Friday, 5 August 2011

Art Therapy in Bangalore - a Conversation with Brother Mani. Part - 1


Is art for artists? Or can anyone paint?

Art isn’t about beautiful paintings or vases it is a personal expression.
You don’t have to be an artist to be an art therapist or to be a participant in art therapy.

The post modern idea that art need not be restricted to a canvas or have perfection is what drives art therapy.



I met Brother Mani a few months back when he was conducting a workshop on art therapy. Brother Mani is an art therapist

This is an interview where Brother Mani speaks about how art therapy can be transformative and therapeutic.


Here's as link to the interview


There is a second part of this interview, which is a bit longer which I will post in a day or two.

The pictures are made by the students who attended the program. 









Scientific therefore neutral


Does science = neutrality ? This is  an assumption we take for granted in the modern era(by modern I refer to the era during and post enlightenment). We have come to believe that science unlike religion is more informed and is rational. The term rational is quite problematic as it assumes there is something irrational. It creates a dichotomy between ancient and medieval and modern. Modern being a better state. The realm of the other 2 eras is relegated to being romanticised or being seen through biased eyes.

Our idea that science is rational when compared religion or belief is misleading, science is never neutral. The assumption that cutting something of from its natural environment and studying it will give us a neutral response. Psychology is one such discipline that desperately tries to use scientificity as a means to justify its end. At it heart lies the assumption that it can acquire the same status as the natural science if its methods are mimic those used in the natural sciences. Statics come to the rescue here; breaking something down into numbers will apparently make it more scientific.

This fallacy has often lead to disastrous results by scientists conducting scientific research. One of my favourite examples is intelligence and intelligence testing. Intelligence is a badly defined concept and one that most psychologists do not agree upon. On this shaky foundation intelligence tests were constructed using scientific means. The Nazis picked up on these ideas of inferiority and superiority as a basis for killing people. this of course is well documented history and an extreme example. There are a lot more horror stories but I will skip them. Today intelligence tests help separate students with difficulties from well functioning children. We set up special schools for such children. All of this can hide behind the guise of being helpful and science.

We have come to believe in science as something that will give us the right answers. I use the term ‘believe’ deliberately because we don’t question its authority and believe in its benign presence. We assume that if an idea has some scientific backing it is good and correct and neutral.

Science however is never neutral, and it can never be. By writing a certain way or by following certain methods and idea does not become neutral. Natural science isn’t neutral. It takes a certain amount of conjecture and intuition to prove something in the natural sciences. The natural sciences are learning to live with uncertainty. Psychology however needs to prove the existence of things that are merely constructed by it. By hiding behind the guise of pseudo neutrality psychology subtly pushes its own agenda.

Most scientific ideas are based in not so neutral ideas. Take for example eugenics, which sorted out good healthy people from the ones that were useless to society. This idea has taken the form of cultural differences or gender differences. Women are not unclean creatures (not a medieval idea as we like to assume) but they are trapped by their biology. PMS syndrome is presented as evidence for a woman’s weakness and her inability to be as competent as a man. The people behind such research are not consciously trying to suppress women nor are a part of a grand conspiracy; they are products of their environment in which women internalise passive roles.

Good science if there is such a thing isn’t about proving something it is more profound than that, it is about accepting that a problem may not have an answer or the answer isn’t what one hoped for or that the answer isn’t dependent on the method.

Science has come to take the place of religion. Lets not say but religion was false and look at how it oppressed people. This is a weak argument that goes nowhere. Lets not assume religion was universally bad and science is universally good and is helping us become rational beings. We can’t discard either. We need to question both. Lets not assume that a sterile lab can give us all the answers we are looking for and we can do things better.  The egocentricism that modernity has assumed towards other forms of thought are repressive.

I am attaching 2 links one to a program which is aired on BBC Horizon which starts with the question how long is a piece of string. This program challenges the idea of observation and measurement as an absolute.

The second link if for a documentary by Adam Curtis- All Watched By Machines Of Loving Grace. This documentary looks at how we have come to believe that technology will set us free and how ideas of order and balance have been oppressive.  The documentary a lot of interpretations these are just two of them that I thought complimented the paper.
this link is for part one of four.