Saturday, 29 March 2014

Not such an equal marriage


The seamier side of things

Last night I read two important stories on the internet – UK allows gay marriage, Gay man kills wife when she threatened to expose him.

The first story showed pictures showed happy white people from LGBT groups holding hands, kissing. The other story also UK based was sickening on so many levels. A British  man of Indian origin had gone back to India to find a suitable bride whom he eventually killed. His wife found out he was gay and threatened to leave him this is when a fight ensued and he killed her and burnt her body.
While a certain section of British society is celebrating its freedom another is living with dark secrets. The hypocrisy of Indian society never fails to sicken me. So this couple married presumably to make their parents happy fulfil a role society expects of them and it turned out so wrong. The whole idea of the marriage seemed wrong so he met and rejected girls who he met once- because marriage is a bit like mating dogs. He knew he was gay and decided to marry a woman instead of coming out. The girls family thought it was a good idea to let their daughter marry a man they had only just met and lived in different country.

It is sad that this young woman lost her life in such a brutal way. Looking at comments on Indian news websites most people were of the opinion that this man had the freedom of coming out in a country like UK, he could have moved to another town, he was financially independent the law was on his side. The deceit and cowardice cost a young woman her life.

It also points to the ugliness that surrounds Indians marriages. We marry our children because it is the respectable thing to do. Men and women are introduced to each other through matchmakers after one or two meetings they decide to get married. This comes from an sexually repressed society which frowns upon men and women talking to one another it sees no problem in promoting the idea of institutionalised rape.

While a section of British society celebrates equal marriages another one lives a life of deceit, hiding, disguising and even murdering. While the law in UK on this issue is equal when it comes to colour it needs to be less insular when it comes to LGBT activism. 

Thursday, 6 February 2014

The cultural ghetto that Manchester can be.




Don’t get me wrong I love this city but like every city it has its problems. To me the most obvious one is the ghettos ethnic minorities live in or are relegated to. While its nice to have a space of ones own the racial segregation in these localities bothers me.

Drunk students on a Friday night drinking too much out for a curry and vomit. A little taste of the orient in China town. Is that what we are? Cute people of colour who cook exotic food. Is this how culture is to be consumed? Bright shop fronts which hide dark realities of our existence. With segregation comes ghettos, barely a mile away from The Famous ‘Curry Mile’ is Longsight the Asian ghetto, police sirens and ambulances used to greet me whenever I went there (so I stopped going). Similar stories of sleaze and gendered violence can be told in any of these exclusive localities of Manchester.

Manchester is probably one of the few places the world I have met people from so many nationalities but that is an elite migrating population. For the most people who have lived here long enough ghettos are a reality. What's more there is not talk of integration we are meant to remain in our place. We are to remain preserved in time and our cultures preserved. We can't be individuals only a group of people who function as a collective, on display to be used and abused. We are commodities to be served up as hot curries. This separation while amusing to a dominant few is detrimental to these communities that have been carefully preserved. We are exotic others who will never be British living on the benevolence of people who like foreign things. 

To say that crime is a racial thing would play straight into the hands of racists however not to talk about these issues would be as much an injustice. 


Wednesday, 22 January 2014

Is homosexuality my culture? Why I do not agree with the emotive ‘this is our culture argument’.


In the past few months I have been following the news about section 377 while I think the law will only legitimise hate crime the discussion around it is what bothers me. Either side claiming cultural supremacy on this issue it has forgotten something vital that law in India tries to position itself above culture. Those in favour of brining back the law think of homosexuality as a western disease which will corrupt ‘Indian culture’. Those in favour of legalising homosexuality call for respecting our culture and shedding Victorian morality. While both sides do have a point about culture they forget something vital about this fight- sexual orientation is not cultural choice and that which is cultural is changeable. While the expression of sexuality is dictated by cultural and historical factors these are constantly changing. Surprisingly the same debate about culture is taking Nigeria. Both pro and anti arguments invoke notions of ‘true Nigerian culture’. If legalising homosexuality is not ‘Indian culture’ neither is criminalising it.

What I fear in this debate is that culture will be the focus and not homosexuality and people who are homosexual. In a nation where hate crime by the state are justified the law needs to go above arguments about culture and religious sentiment, after all we are a multi cultural and multi religious nation. The law is not based on personal liking but on ethics. While homosexuality might be distasteful to someone it does not justify violence. Consensual sex between people of the same sex (legal age taken into consideration) is not a crime it does not harm people or society. 

Update on 14th October 2014

I have just heard this lecture by Rahul Rao -The locations of homophobia this sums up my thoughts on why I resist the narrative 'homophobia is not native to my culture'. Nativism is something I resist personally and as an academic discourse. The LGBT issue is a pertinent one however either side builds this historical narrative which does not tackle the issue in the present. I will let you read the the paper and decide for yourself. 

Click the link below for a copy of the essay. 
The locations of homophobia -Rahul Rao

Tuesday, 14 January 2014

The culture of being offended.



While on recent flight to India I was offered drinks I asked if they served any mulled wine . Promptly I was told this was against company policy as celebrating Christmas would be seen as offensive. ‘To whom?’ I asked ‘to our Indian passengers madam’. I did not bother asking why it is the case of the British speaking for the other as usual. India is a secular nation we celebrate as many festivals as we can, the state even gives us holidays to do so. I have grown up celebrating festivals with friends of every religion. While in recent years we have become intolerant we aren’t trying to annihilate religion in order to achieve some pseudo idea of peace.

Things are not ideal in India religious minorities face persecution, however the state does not deny people the right to practice their religions. We can tell the difference between religion and fundamentalism. In Britain, on the other hand all signs of religion equal fundamentalism and superstition. I suspect this is a cause for a lot of antagonism amongst immigrants who are offended by the lack of symbols and sanctity in public life.

I have grown up learning about religions through festivals. Food offered by neighbours and friends was a way to know them better.  It was an earnest gesture which said look I think you are important enough for me to share my traditions with you. While I wont romanticise religion I wont demonise it either. Yes some wars are caused due to religion some wars are also caused by greed. I found the airlines pre-emptive politically correct stance offensive. I am a vegetarian why not ban meat on the fight? There would have been Brahmins and vegans on the why not ban all animal products then.

The guilt most British people feel for being British never ceases to amaze me. Religion, food, festivals traditions do not racially attack people, people attack people. This suppression of British culture has led to a quiet  animosity against people of colour. While we are to be known by our culture and spirituality the white person must be stripped of these and made to feel invisible. As a friend pointed out recently isn’t white a colour? This stripping away of ones identity also affects the way a person of colour is treated polite on the surface but still thought of as an invader.

What I would personally like to see in the Britain is not pseudo guilt over things that are not offensive. 

Thursday, 15 August 2013

Tell me about your childhood

Or the perverts idea of comfort....

Oh my daughter should talk to you she wants to be a counsellor...... all her friends confide in her...... mine too.... I think I have a talent....

If I had a penny every time  I have heard that said ...... The idea that we are all disturbed and can only be healed by a warm loving soul is getting tiresome. I do think human suffering is  problem that needs tackling I am not so sure confiding in these helpers of society is always the right answer. For most part these are people who have barely put their own house in order and seem to take a perverse delight in other people's misfortunes.

If suffering isn't pleasant neither is dealing with it, when someone tells me they enjoy solving other people's problems I suspect their motives. I am suspicious of the fact that they need to boast about it. feeding off another person's misery is the lowest and most ungracious thing to boast about.

It isn't surprising though we live in an era where are expected to reveal all be tormented by secret mental conditions, to discover our true selves.  Our emotions are to be put on display and the magicians who can swish them away are the new powerful class. Directing our every move feeding off our misery  in a self contentment that can only come from a deluded sense of self.

Maybe I am being too harsh but I have had enough of Psychiatry's little helpers.


Adam Curtis did a nice piece about this a while back think it is somewhere on this blog.


I had to add this wonderful quote The urge to save humanity is almost always a false front for the urge to rule -H.L. Mencken

Wednesday, 17 July 2013

The Virgin Mary and books.

Last week I was at the National Gallery in London. Being the medievalist I think I am I couldn't pass up the opportunity to look at rooms full of medieval art. It is interesting how early representations of The Virgin Mary almost always showed her reading. Engrossed deeply in her book almost unaware of the Angel Gabriel about to tell her she is to conceive a child. Even more nurturing  examples of her with baby Jesus almost always depict her with a book in hand. 

The paintings reflect the artists own social climate but also the way they imagine this piece of history. I am a bit tired of the whole medieval women were oppressed and all they did was wait in their helplessness for the renaissance. The evidence is out there. 

These paintings have  an implication it has on our theology and also on the way we constructed gender. Women and their education must have been an issue women reading books must have been an ideal. I am no theologian but those images convey a certain truth about my faith.

Searching through the internet I found this article which explains the symbolism of the paintings better than I would. 
http://campus.udayton.edu/mary/meditations/olbook.html

Case in point. This paintings is from  The Mérode Altarpiece by Robert Campin It was created between 1425 and 1428.


Sunday, 23 June 2013

Myths about colonialism



This will be a reoccurring post and will deconstruct myths about colonisation. Yes, I know colonisation was terrible but it was not genocide. I am tired of it getting misrepresented because it has consequences on people living in former colonial nations. The idea that we were passive observers of our own destruction  


Myth 1- The English language was imposed on us.

  • At present (2014) the Republic of India does not have a national language. However, we have official languages- Hindi (in the Devanagari script) and English. India has over 700 languages and dialects. State languages are equally represented. 
  • A highly Persianized and technical form of Urdu was the lingua franca of the law courts of the British administration in Bengal, Bihar and the North-West Provinces & Oudh. Until the late 19th century, all proceedings and court transactions in this register of Urdu were written officially in the Persian script. In 1880,  Sir Ashley Eden, the Lieutenant-Governor of Bengal abolished the use of the Persian alphabet in the law courts of Bengal and Biharand ordered the exclusive use of  Kaithi  a popular script used for both Urdu and Hindi Given the diversity of languages we have always chosen one spoken by the majority.
  • In late 1964, an attempt was made to expressly provide for an end to the use of English, but it was met with protests from states such as  Tamil Nadu, West Bengal, Karnataka Puducherry and Andhra Pradesh. Some of these protests also turned violent.
  • Given the kind of ethnocentrism we have towards our regional languages English is neutral.
  • Learning English does not mean you wont remember another one. There is such a thing as multilingualism.


The idea of us being forced to learn English and not our mothers tongues is lovely for a few sado masochists who enjoy hearing stories of the Raj and its many oppressions or for Indian nationalists. It might be good to back a few centuries in the pure past for a few but for most of us adapting to a language that can help us expresses our current reality suits us best.  Partha Chatterjee's essay   - Whose Imagined Community? questions this assumption by pointing out how the writing in regional languages was encouraged displacing Persian (the language of bureaucracy). 

Reference- Chatterjee, P. (1991). Whose imagined community?. Millennium-Journal of International Studies, 20(3), 521-525.



Tuesday, 4 June 2013

We used to be known for cinema now we have man and woman dancing around a tree.




I am using films as a methodology in my thesis. Discussing this the other night with a friend made me realise while Indian cinema is now technologically at par with the west it lacks something fundamentally when it comes to writing stories. This has not always been the case. Bollywood films have at times toppled the dominance of Hollywood winning awards and being remembered for telling universal stories that people could relate to. Between the 1940’s and the present day a lot has changed, from this noble, uplifting thing we now have a cinema that says nothing about the human condition but titillates and creates an imagined India. 
The obvious cardboard sets, painted scenery and hastily put costumes were not a hindrance when it came to telling the story. Post independence cinema had all the elements we now consider hallmarks of Bollywood yet they were not mere entertainment. Even the minor characters contributed in some way. I remember watching black and white films about challenging the caste system, skin colour, unwed mothers and so many issues which are still realties. I do not see those films anymore. The 80’s for me was a decade of films with ear piercing romantic songs, man woman and lots of synchronised dancing around trees. The 90’s was about action films. Then the 2000’s saw a return to fluff and over the top affluence and glamour. I do remember art films but they were too few and in recent years always are banned. Often because they depicted a sexual scene, funny as there is worse stuff on mainstream cinema. I have seen mainstream popular films and frankly, they are not the stuff to watch with your kids or anyone for that matter. Art films deglamourise sex yet they become contentious.
What has changed since 1950? Why have we become complacent? We seem to have become a culture that is content to see women’s bodies being used and abused on screen all in the name of entertainment. We seem to look at a screen for three hours and not think or be challenged.


Wednesday, 8 May 2013

Did you know 20 p in the third world can do wonders…..



Charity is a wonderful thing when done correctly. I have seen too much of it go wrong which is why I clutch at my purse tightly when some approaches me to help people in exotic 3rd world lands. Being a third world citizen myself I am fully aware of the problems my country faces. It is manner in which this charity is done which makes me angry. Now no longer savages we are noble savages albeit starving ones who would not know what a tap was even if it hit us. Gap year students visit us in the sprit of helping less fortunate people their ancestors might have colonised. A deep sense of guilt and shame is chief motivation to help and right all past wrongs. Yes, aspects of colonialism were terrible however we are free nations now who want to forget our pasts- we have moved on.

The sprit of the thing never feels right middle class kids slumming it out in the third world doing more harm than good. Never listening to us always thinking for us. Seems like history is repeating itself. Are we never to be independent of their gaze? Are we never to be treated as equals, only as poor beggars?
It also positions the poor against each other the poor in first world countries realise they mean nothing either to the government or to their middle classes. In short they are scroungers. Now the same class of people in another nation are to be pitied, deserving of charity. The hypocrisy and injustice makes me angry. It pits people against each other and eroticises poverty in the third world. It creates divides amongst races. Dark skinned people are not expected to do much except wait for white saviours to rescue them, never allowed to aspire always on display.

It is worth asking where all this charity money goes? I am not the first person to ask this. Foreign aid has had negative repercussions on our nations, it fosters corruption and creates suspicion. It is not healthy for growth, but these are not issues to bring up in front of a wide-eyed white student lest they accuse you of racism and callousness. Yes brown as I am I am accused of racism. I am the one who is to be reviled as a middle class person I am the problem in the third world not its solution I am not a noble poor person. I am difficult, which is another way of them saying we have met someone who can talk back.

The benign , patronisng gaze of the white aid worker is not as harmless as it would seem it makes the same old mistakes but more gently, it still holds the same assumptions about dark skinned natives. 

Thursday, 18 April 2013

Post Delhi Gang Rape- The Justice Verma Commission

Interesting article -Crimes of Exclusion by  Siddharth Narrain. 
http://kafila.org/2013/03/30/crimes-of-exclusion-siddharth-narrain/

The rape case in Delhi brought a lot of public anger which led to changes in the law which he discusses in this article. 

Wednesday, 17 April 2013

St Dymphna Seminars, 2013 Manchester

The St Dymphna Seminars was created in 2012 to provide a safe and open environment for those with an interest in mental health to  discuss issues relating to practice and experience. Inspired by the models of community care in traditions established at Gheel, the seminars aim to educate and reveal aspects of living with mental illness and perspectives on predominant models and treatments that are rarely shared. It is hoped that these seminars will also provide an arena for conflicting stances to witness the reality behind the ideology.

Here is t link to the website. http://theswordandfettereddevil.wordpress.com/about/

Thursday, 3 January 2013

Gentrification = whitewashing.


You in you small corner and I in mine ..... 

Oh you won’t like it is a very gentrified place. Said a friend to me what she wanted to say was you are brown and that is a white middle class or affluent locality. The term has come to mean one thing only – affluent white people. this is problematic for two reasons one it assumes only white people can be affluent. Two it assumes people of colour come on one class alone- poor.

Areas marked out for their diversity are also the poorest and have some of the highest crime rates. It is all we have to aspire to preserve our culture for public consumption. While I don’t deny our communities have problems they are divided on class lines too just like they are in white society. 


Thursday, 25 October 2012

Ian Parker's suspension

 Mike Cushman


If we have got to a point in UK universities where raising concerns with colleagues is a disciplinary offence then we have deteriorated even further than I thought.
If Professor Parker had gone outside the University without exhausting internal procedures then there may have been grounds for action (although whistle blowing protection may have covered that as well) but he didn't.
The violent over-reaction of management leads an outside observer to believe that they have serious misdemeanours to hide or maybe they just want to be rid of a trade union activist. If so they w=should wait a few months till the Government removes any vestige of protection form people who are willing to speak up for and represent their fellow staff. 

This article was printed in The Independent. 


  • Manchester Metropolitan: 'Bullying' university bans world-renowned professor who spoke out

    Do sign the petition Ian Parker should get back to his work


    Friday, 5 October 2012

    Intrepid traveller in London

    The Museum of Natural History 
    At the Victoria and Albert Museum

    Accessible Academia

    Rather interesting link to  the CENTRE FOR CONTEMPORARY STUDIES based in Bangalore. the good thing is that their talks are recorded and can be found on their  podcasts page. 

    Thursday, 28 June 2012

    The Betrayal of the Western Church

    http://apostlethomasindia.wordpress.com/2012/04/29/pope-denies-st-thomas-evangelized-south-india-ishwar-sharan/

    Making the claims of us 'Indian Christians' seem like myths we created out of active imaginations says a lot about how the west needs to prove it's legitimacy and perpetrate the myth that it converted us barbarians. This denial strengthens the right wing which likes to see us as the illegitimate children left behind by colonial rule, which thinks of our existence is wrong. Then the western church wonders why we dont want to be a part of it. When our own family betrays us it is hard to expect any charity from strangers.